new bounce over 2 and a half men and how did karen and david not get through, as soon as it was between karen and david and jean I knew they would go with jean as they don't like magic acts nothing against jean I liked her made me smile but karen and david should have gone through

At least Herbie didn't win.

He was seriously the worst ever 'singer' who's ever been on BGT. He made DJ Talent sound like Pavarotti.

I know... it should have been David/Karen and either Up and Over It or Two and a half Men... gutted at the result as New Bounce were tedious and awful.

I think that should have been the top 3 but my problem with up and over it would be what could they do in the final to win I think that let them down a bit

I so agree, David and Karen should have walked it ... the boy band were really average

I'm not really shocked anymore.

So the final will now consist of child singer/group and 2 keyboard players ...... talk about dull.

I've always believed the winner should be a variety act like Diversity, Spellbound etc. Personally I think singers should be banned from entering BGT as that's what X Factor is for!

I love variety acts... and to be honest, I can't bear most singers on BGT - I don't know why they don't enter X Factor, I guess they don't think they could win it, because it's tougher. I can understand opera singers auditioning though. Singing children on the other hand... :yawn:

Yeah I was disappointed tonight - only just watched it as I was out and had to Sky+ it.

The top 4 (last 4?) tonight were fairly predictable and for me I would have chosen the other two but there you are - thats the judges and it's maybe even what the public (and Simon Cowell) want - but it isn't what I want.

Of the 4 acts so far qualified for the final I seriously hope none of them wins it, but I have got to the stage of not being surprised by anything any more

2½ Men should definitely have gone through...