--suddenly means they arn't true. Why should we take their words any higher than someone elses? Surely they should be taken less serious since they are gaining financially from this...considerably.

And to people who think its impossible a 12 year old could lie when asked about it....umm if I knew my family would become rich and I'd become rich....id argue black is white until my death bed.

And yet you choose to believe an anonymous internet blog post.

First you start with evidence that something happened,if their is no evidence then it is a load of crap. Do you have any evidence? Did the person making the allegation have any evidence? Since they don't have the balls to reveal their names I would assume not.

Before you can question their denials you need something tangible to be denied, so far it all looks like a load of crap.

No I dont choose to believe anyone. Although I could understand such allegations. Its not as if it would be the surprise of the century or anything.

Where's your evidence that they are "considerably" gaining financially ?

I hope it isn't the aforementioned anonymous internet blog post written by someone with a simon cowell fixation ?

Umm no its my own logic. Clearly the kid is probably never gonna have to do another normal job in his life after this. Whatever happens he will be working in some form of entertainment or music.

So ys, he and his family will gain VERY financially.

If Ronan wins tonight, I hope you will see it may not be a load of crap.

I'm not sure him winning would prove anything, can you elaborate on this please?

But how does this prove they are lying? There is no more evidence the mother is lying than there is that the e-mail is true. And yet you are happy to make assumptions to say that she must be lying. Talk about twisting facts to suit your agenda,

i think the X Factor and BGT are as crooked as a $3 bill

the manipulation and exploitation is disgusting

but that "memo" was nonsense. All the allegations unproven and anything written by an anonymous person on a blog has as much weight as a digitalspy forum post.

there are better and more credible ways to whistleblow. If what they said was true they could have brought down both BGT and xfactor.

But as it was they just provided more publicity to the show. Or maybe that was the point all along