I didn't think she was miming at the time, but it does seem to be a high opinion here so - Live or Mime?

Mime!

My immediate thought was that she was miming.

She has a beautiful voice but I did think she was miming tonight.

Of course she was miming!

was my first reaction too - also straight away said that wasn't her voice; so unnatural.....

Live I reckon. Hopefully Stephen will clarify on BGMT as people will be asking ITV on Twitter.

Maybe she was resting her voice on doctors orders so they used her own recording from the CD?

I thought at the start she might of be mining, it's amazing that a voice that strong and powerful came from a child like her, i would like to think she really did sing it

Either way it was HER voice and she is truly amazing. It doesnt matter if she was miming. If she was, then it was bloody spot on miming.

Oh FGS, this has been done to death when she appeared on AGT.

It's quite depressing that we've come to the point where we don't believe someone could actually have talent.

Live ---- People thought charlotte church was miming when she first appeared at about 12 but she wasn't

Just because it's unusual doesn't mean it's fake

Still a brat whichever way

Definitely miming tonight, but she has a beautiful voice.

This. And considering half of the global stars on the show mime, if an 11 year old girl did it live then that's really impressive indeed.

she is brilliant .makes jai look like amateur

Should check her birth certificate. She sounds at least 30..maybe she's a dwarf!

If the backing track she was miming to is her actual voice then she has a staggeringly good voice for such a young girl, but she was absolutely 100% miming.

Compare how she sounded to Ms. Shirtswinger on the results show - she was singing live. The simplest way to tell is by watching the mouth as the person sings. You could see the little girl's mouth wasn't quite matching up to the backing track.