ok, so she's only made 2 albums but we should be due for another one soon surely.

Currently decorating but listening to Breakup, which has to be one of my all time favourite albums (I guess that's more thanks to Pete Yorn than Scarlett).

Just wondered if there was anyone else on here who likes her stuff?

I Love her stuff actually. Same as you, I prefer Break Up to Anywhere I Lay My Head, but I think both are actually surprisingly good. Relator especially is such a great song.

Relator is a great song isn't it . I also love I Don't Know What To Do and I am The Cosmos, in fact like I say, I just adore the whole album, really surprised it got a critical bashing though .

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ABMBJ9jT-w

Yeah, I loved it too. I think the thing that got the critics was it's similarity to She & Him, although to me they're actually quite different bands - only the female actress + country musician combination was really similar in my eyes. I guess She & Him got there first, and so Pete & Scarlett were seen to be copying, even if they recorded first. Either way it was an incredibly strong album that should have done a lot better.

I always thought she was an actress

ah, I see. Never could get my head around lukewarm reception it got.


yep, she is.