Hi this is my first post so be nice. after watching agmgtw I don't melody is safe. We know she grows up to be river but can't time be rewritten.

This is the Moff were talking about. He could still save her.
Also welcome to the forum.

Thanks for the welcome. I just think it would make for a more inserting second half if it turned out that the doctor is unable to save melody/river.

I know it would be interesting but as River says.

Hmm I didn't think about that. I suppose I don't want Amy and Rory to leave they are hands down the best companions in new who.

unfortunatly it does looks like they are leaving.

Unfortunately something must go wrong in the bringing up of Melody, if she is the one stuck in the impossible astronaught space suit, and then left to wander the new york streets dying then regenerating. This of course leads eventually to a rebellious River Song who kills a good man (rumoured to be her dad Rory) then spends a lot of her life in jail!

I agree that the bringing up will go bad. Also I do think Rory gets killed by river. Poor guy how many times has he died now due to trying to save Amy or the doc. But I think there's more to the last centurion then we think that and when in roman armour Rory is a badass.

I think we've already seen she's not safe tbh.

I meant what if she doesnt die in fotd but dies early due to wibbly wobbly spacey wacyness

The Doctor does say "On my life she will be safe." Maybe her safety is linked to his dying... or maybe I'm overanalysing.

that might work. that damm moffat he makes us come up with all these carckpot theroys but we love him for it