Originally Posted by Redneck Rounder:
“i did say im not sure but i assumed it was rose because it was past tense i think.”
Idris had a major problem with tenses all through the episode. She couldn't say goodbye or hello in the right order, either.
Remember, to her when she was a TARDIS things wouldn't run from one thing to the next - the TARDIS is everywhere in space and time, all at the same time. So everything that could happen or would happen is happening all at the same time to her.
Then she gets stuck inside a limited meat sack that only runs in 3 dimensions effectively, and the fourth at a snail's pace...
Of course she's not going to know which tense to use.