• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Regenation Question?
bingoman
07-06-2011
We know that the Doctor and the Timelords and now Riversong can reganated but one thing that is puzzling me after the revalation about Riversong and ho she can Regenate can the Doctors other Campaions also regenated aswell

If they have been in the Tardis and be going through time and space and the Vortex like Riversong had when she was Baby can the likes of Rose, Ace and say Amy Regenated into somebody new amking them Part Human Part Time Lord

It does make a intresting new Theory for Doctor Who Fan to think about
GangerOfAGanger
07-06-2011
River seems to be a special case because she was conceived in the TARDIS. It's not the travelling that caused the part-timelordness.
Old Man 43
07-06-2011
Originally Posted by bingoman:
“We know that the Doctor and the Timelords and now Riversong can reganated but one thing that is puzzling me after the revalation about Riversong and ho she can Regenate can the Doctors other Campaions also regenated aswell

If they have been in the Tardis and be going through time and space and the Vortex like Riversong had when she was Baby can the likes of Rose, Ace and say Amy Regenated into somebody new amking them Part Human Part Time Lord

It does make a intresting new Theory for Doctor Who Fan to think about”

I think the point about River Song is that she was conceived in the TARDIS. Also she has been subject to genetic manipulation in the womb.

So the answer is probably not.
MrPowered
07-06-2011
Nah, it's only River right now. It's because she was conceived whilst in the Time Vortex.

Adult content:

Spoiler
Basically when Amy and Rory were having sex, the sperm hit the egg inside Amy whilst they were traveling through the Time Vortex.
rostaria
07-06-2011
Hi.
Firstly there is no proof that River can regenerate.
but say we go with the theory that she does.
River was concieved in the time vortex and some how some of the energy went into River. Then Amy was stolen and kept in a chamber for 9 months where I think madame K has been playing mad scientist inject the feotus with god knows what over a nine month period. This creates a Humanplus or Timelordish as I like to call her.

This wouldnt have affected any of the other companions because they werent concieved in the Time Vortex nor were they injected with god knows what.
Helbore
07-06-2011
According to the episode, the Time Lords gained their abilities because they were exposed to the time vortex via the untempered schism over a period of billions of years. It wasn't a quick process and the Doctor considered it impossible.

However, a bit of added information suggested that certain circumstances led to River/Melody's unusual formation. One was that she was conceived whilst the TARDIS was in flight in the time vortex and the other was that she was then manipulated udring the pregnancy to accelerate the genetic modification.

So no, the effects of travelling in the time vortex would not be significant on a fully-formed adult human.
SnoopyChicken
07-06-2011
Originally Posted by MrPowered:
“Nah, it's only River right now. It's because she was conceived whilst in the Time Vortex.

Adult content:

Spoiler
Basically when Amy and Rory were having sex, the sperm hit the egg inside Amy whilst they were traveling through the Time Vortex.
”

Their might be something else at play here as well, the doctor said it took a very long time for the time vortex to have any effect on his ancestors.
Ethel_Fred
07-06-2011
Originally Posted by Helbore:
“However, a bit of added information suggested that certain circumstances led to River/Melody's unusual formation. One was that she was conceived whilst the TARDIS was in flight in the time vortex and the other was that she was then manipulated udring the pregnancy to accelerate the genetic modification.”

Perhaps the modifications aren't stable - thus the need for the spacesuit and why the Girl wasn't surprised when she regenerated.

Originally Posted by SnoopyChicken:
“Their might be something else at play here as well.”

The Tardis itself.
sebbie3000
08-06-2011
Originally Posted by bingoman:
“We know that the Doctor and the Timelords and now Riversong can reganated but one thing that is puzzling me after the revalation about Riversong and ho she can Regenate can the Doctors other Campaions also regenated aswell

If they have been in the Tardis and be going through time and space and the Vortex like Riversong had when she was Baby can the likes of Rose, Ace and say Amy Regenated into somebody new amking them Part Human Part Time Lord

It does make a intresting new Theory for Doctor Who Fan to think about”

We do not know this yet. It is merely implied - but by no means is it definite, yet.

Although there is a strong possibility that the little girl is River, we do not know it for sure yet.
MissTinkerbell
09-06-2011
Originally Posted by Ethel_Fred:
“The Tardis itself.”

Possibly because Idris told Rory that the only water in the forest was the river and the next time we hear that is when River is explaining who she is to Amy.
Gene the Cow
09-06-2011
That's only because she exists at all points of space and time simulataneously
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map