Originally Posted by BlackTarantula:
“Even so, a certain level of respect for Christianity is missing in Corrie. Didn't Roy lambaste Emily Bishop when she tried to reassure him about Hayley in the context of God and Heaven, for instance? There's something sad about seeing it get that sort of stick on TV. Roy's turmoil was understandable, but you know what I mean.
I wonder if people of other faiths are unphased when they see those sort of scenes, or if they find themselves relating in some way to my discomfort.”
“Even so, a certain level of respect for Christianity is missing in Corrie. Didn't Roy lambaste Emily Bishop when she tried to reassure him about Hayley in the context of God and Heaven, for instance? There's something sad about seeing it get that sort of stick on TV. Roy's turmoil was understandable, but you know what I mean.
I wonder if people of other faiths are unphased when they see those sort of scenes, or if they find themselves relating in some way to my discomfort.”
Maybe people of the Christian faith, but I wouldn't have thought others would. They probably wouldn't know (or care) about it because they don't know the religion, just as most Christians don't know much about Judaism or the Islamic faith. Most don't realise that the Koran and the Bible are very similar. Perhaps someone who practises a religion other than Christian, or who has studied other faiths, would be able to say whether they would be discomforted by those sorts of scenes if it was their faith. Personally they didn't bother me because I'm not a practising Christian, although I was christened, went to Sunday school and married in a Church of England church.
I also don't think many Christians would be worried about the scenes between Emily and Roy because they are very likely to happen in the emotional situation of death, but because they respect each other as people they see each others point of view, even if they don't agree with them and it causes friction at the time.
There's a very fine line the writers have to be careful not to cross when it comes to race, religion, life and death and some other areas. They have to come close to make it real and interesting to enable discussion, but without causing real offence. Difficult.





Block storytelling is out in full force at the moment.