But Rihanna has done 5 albums where as Bey has just released her 4th.

Is this HONESTLY a thread? I'm not a huge Beyonce fan but to compare Nicole Scherzinger to her is just ridiculous. I think Nicole is talented and has a couple of good songs but you can't possibly compare her to Beyonce!?

I'm not sure why everyone's calling it a weird comparison. They seem very similar to me. Both used to be lead singers in a girl group, both are pretty, good singers, good performers etc.

But I think that considering their level of fame and talent, their material is for the most part fairly weak and lacking in personality. I would actually rate Rihanna above either of them, because at least she's released one classic pop album in Rated R. Beyonce's new album is great, her best by a mile, but I'm not sure if it will become a classic.

But anyway, there's more Beyonce songs I like than Nicole songs, but then Beyonce has released three albums more than Nicole. I think Nicole's debut album is better than Beyonce's, but then again they're both pretty rubbish. Its a tough one, I think they're pretty much equal at the moment (considering that Nicole is only just starting out).

There's really no comparison, Beyonce wins hands down. And I'm barely a fan.