Originally Posted by
Takae:
“Thanks for the spelling correction, but what makes their food choices 100% British, though?
Potatoes aren't British as it was introduced to Britain in 16th century. Peas aren't either as it was introduced to Britain in 17th century. Britain said hi to meat pies when the Roman Empire paid a visit. It cannot be "unashamedly 100%, completely, brilliantly British". Historically, "100% British" were rabbit/hare/boar/deer/dog/horse/sheep/fish dishes (yes, pre-Roman people ate dogs), oat meals and bread.
Pedantic, moi?
”
The raises the question of when something becomes "British", or any nationality, after it's been assimilated into the culture. Given that modern people would find almost everything about the early life of the first settlers of this island to be utterly alien, I think we have to assume that things do, at some point, become part of the culture. The most obvious example, perhaps, being the cup of tea.
Besides, if you wanted to be
really pedantic, then you can't complain about pies being a Roman introduction, because before the Romans arrived this island was called Albion. If you want something to come from "Britain" (as opposed to, say, "Britanee"), then you have to wait for the arrival of Modern English in the 16th century. So, if we're
really being pedantic, then none of your objections hold up.