Originally Posted by David-Scotland:
“Much as I hate the STV opt outs - I love Lewis and Midsomer Murders, I've just watched Downton Abbey and to me it's quite a lot of p!sh. Though I did laugh when the announcer trailed it as "downtown" abbey I do think STV might have got it right on this one!”
Hi David
Downton is never going to be everyones cup of tea. But thie first TV appearance of the legend that is Dame Maggie Smith should have alerted the bosses at STV that this was going to be something out of the ordinary in this day and age. Lavish sets, costumes etc and a story reminiscent of Upstairs Downstairs, it more or less had 'hit' written all over it. Audience numbers began high and climbed. It has won countless awards and is the all time best selling TV drama on Amazon. Sales overseas are incredibly high.
I like it and am looking forward to watching the new series. But what angered so many Scots - particularly the more elderly for whom a series like this is wall to wall heaven - was STV's refusal to show it, and come out with dumb statements like
"costume drama does not do well in Scotland"
and then be forced, tail between legs, to quickly screen series 1 as the tremendous backlash made them rethink their loopy decision. Lorraine Kelly, poster girl for all the Scotlands Greatest Mince shows said in a magazine interview last year that DA was her tv highlight of the year. Yet this is the show that her favourite employers denied the ordinary viewers in Scotland.
I said at the time that the STV bosses doubtless live in homes with access to ITV1. If they did not, their own families would probably have lynched them.
The ratings will be interesting. I think at least 1 million Scots will have tuned in. Taggart can only dream of such figures.
Not all ITV1 dramas are good. But to drop established series like Lewis, (we still have series 3 to see), Midsomer, Poirot - and Marple - Doc Martin, Foyle's War etc was shortsighted and incredibly stupid.
The excuses - "not relevant to Scotland" - when we are expected to watch 12 year old US series which were cancelled after 1 season (Fitz) made a mockery of the PR of a once respected broadcaster.