• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • General Discussion Forums
  • Food and Drink
How much hotter is a vindaloo compared to Mardras?
<<
<
2 of 2
>>
>
mrsgrumpy49
05-03-2016
I worked in Uganda for a while - plenty of Ugandan asian food. None of it was eye watering hot. But much of it was South Indian vegetarian, maybe that's the difference.
By the way it does my head in when on TV cooking programmes they use the word spice to mean chillie - and spicy to mean hot, Chillie is a spice but not all spice is chillie (or hot). Ghrrrrr...
Sambda
05-03-2016
Originally Posted by dellzincht:
“So the Indian chef I worked with was lying, I don't think so. Vindaloo may be authentic but it's not something that's eaten often over there.

And Tikka Massala was still invented in India. It's one of the most popular curries in Britain but it's not British.”

In general, an Indian friend of mine said most of the British "Indian" dishes are known about over there but most of what we eat over here falls into occasional/party/feast offerings over there; the everyday dishes are far simpler and far less reliant on huge quantities of meat. They simply don't shovel down conical plates of, say, tikka masala with parathas, pilau rice and lord knows what on a daily basis. You couldn't live on such rich food on a daily basis - for one thing most of them couldn't afford it, and secondly, you'd die with that sort of calorific intake and unbalanced diet. It's full of cream, yoghurt, ghee, creamed coconut, creamed nuts and other saturated-fat-laden stuff.

Same in China. What we eat over here would be the richness of food served at, say, a wedding or family occasion over there.
degsyhufc
05-03-2016
Originally Posted by dellzincht:
“I once worked with an Indian chef who told me that hot curries aren't really a thing in India, over there it's all about the flavour. They make them hot over here purely because that's how the English like them.

Hottest I've ever gone was a Vindaloo and even that was too hot for me. I can't imagine trying a Phaal.”

Originally Posted by JulesF:
“I'm really not sure that's entirely correct. A good curry is definitely about balance of flavours, not just pure heat, but a vindaloo is at least authentically Indian (from Goa, adapted from dishes brought over there by the Portuguese), whereas the much milder and more popular tikka massala was invented in Britain, for British tastes.”

Originally Posted by dellzincht:
“So the Indian chef I worked with was lying, I don't think so. Vindaloo may be authentic but it's not something that's eaten often over there.

And Tikka Massala was still invented in India. It's one of the most popular curries in Britain but it's not British.”



From documentaries about food history, it is almost universally accepted that tikka masala was invented in the UK, possibly Glasgow.

Tikka is marinated pieces of chicken. That is authentic Indian. It was a UK restaurant that made chicken tikka masala in to a dish.
Reportedly because the customer felt his tikka was too dry so asked for some sauce and so the chef knocked up a sauce with some tomato sauce and spices.
Toby LaRhone
05-03-2016
I travelled in Northern India for several weeks.
Not once did we encounter anything recognisable in a UK curry house.
I later did a ten week evening Indian cookery class supervised by a very knowledgeable Indian cook.
One week we made an "authentic" vindaloo.
It was absolutely nothing like the "traditional" curry house vindaloo.
The descriptions "Madras", "Vindaloo" and "Phaal" are simply anglicised measures of heat and, as has been said, will vary enormously between establishments.

Some weeks back I was astonished to notice a "Phaal" in the Indian ready meals at Sainsbury's. I find all supermarket curries much of a muchness but I bought the Phaal out of sheer curiosity. No way could it be ranked with the palate wrecking creations served in curry houses. I would describe it as reasonably hot.
walterwhite
06-03-2016
Originally Posted by dellzincht:
“So the Indian chef I worked with was lying, I don't think so. Vindaloo may be authentic but it's not something that's eaten often over there.

And Tikka Massala was still invented in India. It's one of the most popular curries in Britain but it's not British.”

Perhaps he wasn't from Goa or perhaps he was just a crap chef.
JulesF
06-03-2016
Originally Posted by dellzincht:
“So the Indian chef I worked with was lying, I don't think so. Vindaloo may be authentic but it's not something that's eaten often over there.

And Tikka Massala was still invented in India. It's one of the most popular curries in Britain but it's not British.”

Nope. Wrong.
Bex_123
06-03-2016
Originally Posted by barbeler:
“I'm of the opinion that the stupidly hot curries are only eaten out of bravado by men (always men) who've just drunk about ten pints of lager. I'm sure the curry house staff treat them as a great source of amusement and dose them accordingly.

These days I greatly prefer a dhansak – a curry bursting with flavour that won't destroy your taste buds.”

Female who doesn't drink lager here I'm afraid but love hot curries

I agree with Dhansak though, lovely!

Originally Posted by JulesF:
“ but a vindaloo is at least authentically Indian (from Goa, adapted from dishes brought over there by the Portuguese), whereas the much milder and more popular tikka massala was invented in Britain, for British tastes.”

Isn't an authentic vindaloo actually completely different to our version of a vindaloo, though? I might be wrong, but I'm sure I read that an authentic vindaloo isn't hot like ours is and different flavour too.

In agreement with the tikka massala being invented in Britain though!
mimik1uk
06-03-2016
Originally Posted by Bex_123:
“Female who doesn't drink lager here I'm afraid but love hot curries

I agree with Dhansak though, lovely!



Isn't an authentic vindaloo actually completely different to our version of a vindaloo, though? I might be wrong, but I'm sure I read that an authentic vindaloo isn't hot like ours is and different flavour too.

In agreement with the tikka massala being invented in Britain though!”

i think a traditional vindaloo is still quite hot but is traditionally made with pork and has a wine based sauce , neither you will see in many vindaloos over here

i do like the occasional really hot curry but i do have a preference for a pathia or a dopiaza
Bex_123
06-03-2016
Originally Posted by mimik1uk:
“i think a traditional vindaloo is still quite hot but is traditionally made with pork and has a wine based sauce , neither you will see in many vindaloos over here

i do like the occasional really hot curry but i do have a preference for a pathia or a dopiaza”

Ahh that might have been it, then

Mmm pathia. I had a prawn pathia yesterday, it was amazing.
JulesF
06-03-2016
Originally Posted by mimik1uk:
“i think a traditional vindaloo is still quite hot but is traditionally made with pork and has a wine based sauce , neither you will see in many vindaloos over here

i do like the occasional really hot curry but i do have a preference for a pathia or a dopiaza”

Yes, that's right. It's still very hot, but it does taste different from curry house vindaloo. The slow-cooker recipe I use was given to me by a Portuguese friend and uses pork loin or shoulder, red wine vinegar and LOTS of garlic. The name comes from the Portuguese for wine (vinho) and garlic (alho).
dellzincht
06-03-2016
Originally Posted by JulesF:
“Nope. Wrong.”

To be honest nobody knows for sure where it was invented, there are different theories.

I've heard it could be either but always thought personally it was invented in India and brought over here. The type we eat these days has probably been adapted from an Indian recipe, if anything.
degsyhufc
06-03-2016
I don't eat vinaloo's often but the best I've ever had was homemade using this recipe.


Use as much chilli as you like
http://www.bbc.co.uk/food/recipes/porkvindaloo_89999

It can also be tweaked to make it into a kebab (Souvlaki)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Souvlaki
Meepers
08-03-2016
Originally Posted by WombatDeath:
“Here's a useful tip: curry houses will (in my experience) let you dictate how hot you want your curry to be. So if you want to try a vindaloo to see if you like the taste, but are worried that it might be too hot, ask for something like a vindaloo with the heat of a madras.

It also works the other around; if I'm visiting an Indian place for the first time I will usually have a jalfrezi with the heat of a vindaloo.”

Decent curry houses wouldn't do that, it means they are just dumping in chilli or cream
<<
<
2 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map