Originally Posted by Fudd:
“They don't have the controversial edge this year...I guess that's why they wanted Goldie but I'm glad she pulled out.
I honestly thought they would've got Gamu to audition again this year, but maybe that'll be next time round...especially if Cheryl returns!”
Did she not get deported in the end?
Originally Posted by Glenn A:
“I was reading the Sunday Mirror in the pub a month ago and their critic really savaged The X Factor. However, it still does well in the ratings and the Daily Star seems to feature it on its front page most days.”
Most TV critics do that - it's basically intended just to be an amusing commentary on the show. There's no point doing an actual review (as you would of a new show) for X Factor or Strictly in their 8th years.
Originally Posted by
RobbieSykes123:
“I was reading an interview with Noel Gallagher in The Times yesterday - apparently, Cowell asked him to be his replacement on TXF before turning to Gary Barlow. Worryingly, it sounds like The Chief was considering it too - but it was learning about the "judges' houses" round which meant he would have to "have a fat lass from Bradford standing in me daffodils singing Flying Without Wings" that put him off. 
Apparently his 11 year old daughter has disowned him though.
Could have been interesting from a ratings perspective. Might have brought some fans of credible, proper, non-manufactured, "hard graft" music to the show.
Hell, even I might have tuned in...
”
I don't think Cowell was looking for credible music fans. More that Noel would do something stupid and/or controversial. Tbh, I'm not sure he would have been the answer. Maybe a bit of a novelty at first, I suppose.
Originally Posted by
RobbieSykes123:
“Given I have consistently criticised the Beeb on here over The Voice, I wouldn't bet on that, no matter how well it rates. 
Not that I expect it to be a success. Folk won't watch because they will think it's an X Factor rip off.”
That never stopped people watching X Factor (or Pop Idol for that matter) or The Voice in the US!

They seem to be going down the right route with the judges. I think it could be quite big for them. It's not exactly a difficult sell.
Originally Posted by Dancc:
“Oh dear. I wonder how long it will be until Syco drop him? Joe McElderry the previous year suffered a similar fate.
Not a good advert for the show at all. Of course, we've known for some time it's not about finding someone with 'The X Factor' any more, this just underlines it. Someone with that special something would be selling more records.”
He's signed to a "joint deal" with Columbia which basically means they're managing his career on a day to day basis. I'd guess they'll have a significant say in whether he's dropped - he could be an albums artist to be fair - but the singles performance is so bad that I don't think it's looking good.
It'll be no surprise if Rebecca Ferguson (Syco/Epic), One Direction (Syco) and Cher Lloyd (Syco) sell more than the winner. The public don't seem to be great at picking them! Probably because they tend to go for the safer options in the end. 1D and Cher Lloyd are getting a lot of exposure just now so on that front it's looking quite good (even if it's not an actual winner in the news).