Lol this just occurred....He really does, both average just Frankie is older, IMO I'd imagine Eoghan walking into the audition now being 18 or so, doing and sounding the exact same thing with the 'swagger' and 'prescence'

Awww what has happened to Eggnog... he was shit but atleast he wasn't a c***

He actually sounds worse. I mean I cant really remember much of Eggnog or that XF but I know he never sounded as bad as Frankie has.

LOL, quoted for the truth! And that's from someone who compared him to Eggnogg yesterday!

You know, I never liked Eoghan... but even though his voice was remarkably unremarkable, he actually could sing in tune. Frankie on the other hand, I don't think hit a single note in either song he sang this weekend. So... I don't really think there's much of a comparison there...

Eggnog doesn't come across as a sleazy slime bag

Frankie reminds me of a raw John Lennon singing Twist n' Shout on Please Please Me...

Its just that breathy tone of voice that sound similar, lol I just come across a old performance and he reminds me of frankie with the hair style average vocal and apparent swagger..

Not sure what happened to eggnog he had one album and bombed.

No I think Frankie is worse tbh.

You know, I'm so glad you posted that as it's been driving me mad thinking who he reminds me of.....got it in one.

Eoghan was much, much more likable. Plus he actually gave one good performance ('Imagine') something Frankie will probably never do.

Most of the past contestants have been able to sing in tune.

Some of them were a bit average, but compared to Frankie they're amazing.

I really thought all the Frankie bashing was just the usual DS thing and I haven't been watching so didn't really know, so I went to YT to look for myself.

Quigg was bland and had no "voice" but he was mostly in tune (ish) but I have seen 17 year old lads totally pissed in karaoke bars that sounded better than Frankie. I just cannot understand what they are thinking - he's a serious contestant right?

They can pimp him as much as they want; he's never going to get the votes - not in a million years.

Everyone hated eoghan back in 2008 and now they don't...good old consistent british public lol, slated him whilst on show 3 years later he can sing in tune yet when he was on the show he couldn't..!!!???

Frankie is worse than eggnogg

Umm because its called hindsight. Back then Eggnog was terrible but compared to this Frankie Cococksa shit he's gold.

Eggnog is still shit. Relatively speaking Frankie is worse. Nothing inconsistent about that.

I didn't like eggnog at the time, but he could sing in tune and at least looked clean.

Neither could hold a note!Both kept in cuz silly girls vote

actually eoghain was probably better....and i LOATHED eoghain!!!

Lol well I can't argue with that. 'Cococksa' looool

Eoghan gave two great performances more than Frankie ever will!

I thought never forget was his best lol

he's worse than Eoghan

Well.... he was really.

Storming the stage because he didn't like the result (the croaky voiced girl was voted off, whatever her name was)