Originally Posted by RichmondBlue:
“Sorry, I think it does make sense..if the producers are aware beforehand that a particular contestant is streets ahead of everyone else.
Take the year Ray Quinn won Dancing On Ice, it ceased to be a contest from week one. While it was a joy to watch him skate throughout the remainder of the series, it was against the "spirit" of these sort of programmes.
Anyway, I don't believe we have that problem with Jason. As others have said, he's good, but not THAT good. So far, he's been out in front because of his obvious ability to "sell" some excellent routines..not because of his vastly superior technical ability. As the others gain the experience and confidence to actually perform rather than concentrating on technique, the gap will close.
I also think he's been over-marked, not in comparison to his opponents in this years show (he's justifiably out in front right now) but in comparison to marks given to some of the top dancers in previous series.
Jason may go on to win, but like the others, he'll have to up his game...it's far from a foregone conclusion.”
But Ray Quinn had only been to an ice rink for an occasional treat like for his birthday and didn't even live near an ice rink. How could the producers know that he would be so good? Yes, he could roller blade, but even Chris Dean said that was a different skill to skating on ice and in fact had caused problems in training at the start. The 'problem' with someone like Ray, is he would probably be good at most things he turned his hand to trying, plus he was young (less fear) and very enthusiastic (up for anything). There are people like that, but when they are as young as Ray was when he did DOI, it's not always obvious. He was a Marmite contestant though and it was not a foregone conclusion he would win in the final. The public could have voted Donal MacIntyre (the underdog who came 2nd) or Jessica Taylor (very good and came 3rd) the winner.
I agree though this is not the 'problem' with Jason. Jason already has the experience of appearing in front of a live audience, but he is having to work hard to produce the technical level he is at now and that's a long way from perfect according to the judges and Karen Hardy on ITT.
At the moment the judges are nagging all the celebs about their technique and if Jason doesn't work on his, then he might get to the final, but not win in the end.