Wow, what an amazing voice she has. So glad Simon saw the mistake he had made and brought her back even if it wasn't in the fairest of circumstances. Any other Melanie fans?

Yes I like her now, Think Caitlin and Jazzlynn should have got through instead of Rachel and Tiah and Simone

I'd have chosen Jazzlyn, Torah, Melanie and Rachel.

Ressurecting a slightly older thread here but....I have to agree! ( and I'm a MAHOOSIVE Leona Lewis fan, and have loved her from audition 1.)

But I can deffo say that Melanie Amaro also made the hairs stand up when I heard her sing for the first time - just like they did with Leona!

She reminds me so much of Leona in a lot of ways....

You either think she's really pretty....or people look at you daft (as if to say...wtf!!)

Plus she seems like a 'girl-next-door' type who can really just.... SING (amazingly well!!)

....and she's also got that 'humble' personality that people will either love - or hate! (The 'haters' will probably like someone who flashes the knickers etc or is unbelievably 'gaga-ish'!!)

Stacy's good also....but to me she's just a tad bit too OTT.... so for me - it's Miss Amaro to win!!