She is the best female vocalist on the show and she is a versatile performer who has stage presence.

Kitty probably is the second best performer on the show but vocally is not of the same standard of Misha or even Sophie who has a good voice.

Sophie doesn't have the stage presence or charisma on stage.

Janet doesn't have the voice or charisma on stage as far as I am concerned.

Kitty though is not liked that much by the public hence being in the bottom two and the booing of the audience when she got through on Sunday.

Misha has the full package; she can sing, has stage presence and is a good performer.

Another thing I have noticed is that at least one celeb guest on the Xtra Factor each week have named Misha as their fav contestant and raved about how good she is.

No other contestant has received that consistent praise from at least one celeb guests thus far.

Win or not she will do well as talent always shines through!!

Yeah, that's nice, instead of just commenting on Misha in a Misha appreciation thread, you decide to belittle the other contestants. Real classy.

I wasn't belittling the other contestants at all I was just giving my constructive critique to the other female acts on the show who will be compared and contrasted to each other.

I said that Sophie and Kitty had good vocals but not in my opinion better then Misha's.

I said that I did not like Janet’s voice, plenty of people don't like her voice and I am entitled to comment on that.

I believe Misha has the total package compared to the other singers; however I was not putting the other singers down

Me thinks you are a tad too over sensitive as we can't all like the same people!!!

I just find it kinda odd that you take every possible opportunity to demean the other contestants. Surely it's more positive to simply show support for the acts that you do like? Just saying...

I did not demean the other singers you need to read what I wrote again!!

I am entitled to comment on the other singers whether I like them or not.

However I maintain that I was not demeaning the other singers!!

I'm not a troll. Her voice really is not amazing, not even close to it in my opinion. She has a good voice though, as do several others in the frame. If it was purely a singing competition, she'd have a great chance but we know that it isn't. Sadly perhaps, she will not win because she's average looking at best and does not come accross as a particularly nice person. Craig (not my favourite) also has a good voice but all seem to agree that he's nothing to look at also. He does however come accross as a nice person. He wont win either but possibly has a better chance than Misha.

Furthermore if you think I was demeaning the other singers then you haven't read too many threads on here as you will probably have a Hernia.

Go into any Frankie thread and read some of the comments mentioned about him!!

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder!

There will be people out there who think Craig and Misha are attractive even if you don't!!

So are you saying that she's a 'great artist' on the basis of doing a handful of abridged covers? Maybe you're not.

The difference is that most artists do not rely on popularity competitions to gain entry into the profession. Furthermore, perhaps the arrogant ones only show arrogance once they have earned their dues so to speak. X Factor contestants, even very succesful ones could hardly be regarded as having earned their dues on the basis of high-end karaoke which, let's face it, is essentially what the X Factor showcases..

Jeez, calm down, I was only pointing something out!

Anyhoo, Frankie kinda brings it on himself with his attitude and lack of talent. But I tend to skip over the nastier stuff anyhow.

after trolling through this thread,

ive decided her voice is ok , performance is great, attitude sucks

That is true and I don't think they're particularly unattractive. They're just ordinary looking people. Lets face it, we know what the public like and it's pointless pretending that looks are not a major factor on a show such as this. They just are. It's not an unsurmountable disadvantage, as a couple of previous winners can testify, but it is a disadvantage and coupled with a less than endearing personality (this might change but so far the concensus seems to be that she's not coming accross well) and a voice that is not quite mainstream (in a Leonna or Matt kind of way) she faces a lot of key obstacles. Good luck to her. I'm sure she's a nice girl and she does have a good voice. I have no big favourites this year so far and at this stage would not have a problem with her winning. I just think she wont and that her vocals are maybe a bit overrated

Every modern singer sounds the same. Her vocals are shouty and aggressive. I never liked this kind of compensation for not having the vocal chords to sing correctly. She shouts from her throat, rather than singing from the chest. You want to hear perfect effortless vocals, try Karen Carpenter. This poor excuse for a singer couldn't sing a soft song in tune, it always has to be with aggression and attitude to compensate for the lack of vocals. Unfortunately, people nowadays think this is good as it is popular and sells records. Doesn't mean she is scientifically a good singer; which she isn't.

Positively pleading





I did like her performance on Sat

What does her colour have to do with it? Would you say that if she was white? What a disgusting comment!