Cheryl is useless and ****s over most of her acts once they get to the live shows anyway, don't want her back.
X Factor 2012: Gary, Tulisa , Louis and .... Cheryl!
2 of 2
I wouldn't mind ditching Kelly for Cheryl (though I'd prefer for Dannii to return), but I'd rather lose Gary.
Noel G, Cheryl, Danni and Louis (for comedy value)
I know Noel has already said no... but I reckon if Cowell and the rest of the producers honestly care about the UK version, they should go all out to get him. He's the only man in the music industry who would sit there and actually tell it how it is... whilst also being incrediblt witty.
I know Noel has already said no... but I reckon if Cowell and the rest of the producers honestly care about the UK version, they should go all out to get him. He's the only man in the music industry who would sit there and actually tell it how it is... whilst also being incrediblt witty.
Yeah great....i'd just like to get shot of Kelly...I cant understand a word she's on about....lol....
Cheryl has moved on why cant everyone else she is no longer and never will be again apart of this show! And quite frankly if she ever did it would be an embarresment to her As much of a Cheryl fan i am i actually prefer her not being on it and i`d like the panel to stay the same. And after watching a bit of the US X Factor tonight Simon can stay well clear aswell..
No thank you. Danni maybe. X Factor if back needs to change the format and shift away from all the attention on the judges and get back to attracting some real talent.
It's time someone had a Judge the Judges Show each week, reviewing the antics of X Factor, Strictly and all the lesser beings. A Harry Burp type effort poking fun at their idiot efforts. Would love to see Harry playing Barlow whilst trying to listen Frannkie sing.
It's time someone had a Judge the Judges Show each week, reviewing the antics of X Factor, Strictly and all the lesser beings. A Harry Burp type effort poking fun at their idiot efforts. Would love to see Harry playing Barlow whilst trying to listen Frannkie sing.
Tulisa and Cheryl can't be on the same panel. I'd keep mixing them up.
Would love Dannii back.
Prefer Simon to Gary also.
Would love Dannii back.
Prefer Simon to Gary also.
I don't hate Louise but he seems to be dated on the panel
So my panel would be: Gary, Kelly, Tulissa and another male singer who's younger than Louis (maybe Mark from Westlife ?)
So my panel would be: Gary, Kelly, Tulissa and another male singer who's younger than Louis (maybe Mark from Westlife ?)
Oh good heavens no - two fairly clueless chavs who do not have the ability to articulate constructively and technically any form of adept musical criticism - granted Tulisa is considerably better at that than Cheryl Cole and she seems able to at least attempt the Simon Cowell approach of assessing how current and commerical they are and considering their place in the industry, but both of them would just drive me right up the wall. Bring back Dannii!
Next year it should be Rhianna, Gary, Jackie Woodburne and Cheryl Cole next to one another. The first 2 are talented classy people and the other 2- er, not so talented.
Some have wanted to know why I always compare JW with CC. It's because neither of them have any talent yet both get put on a pedestal-CC doesn't even sing live, had a famous encounter in a public toilet, and uses autotune yet gets made out to be Mother Teresa because she got cheated on and got bitten by a mosquito, while Jackie gets made out to be in the same league as Helen Mirren, Judi Dench and Anjelica Huston despite the fact she's to acting what CC is to singing(if this wasn't the case and she was a talented actress, JW would've done what her on-screen son, Stefan Dennis or Chris Eccleston did and left sooner to do other roles in America/films/other TV shows, rather than stay in a soap opera for 17 years and end up having to be interviewed by Eamonn Holmes)
Some have wanted to know why I always compare JW with CC. It's because neither of them have any talent yet both get put on a pedestal-CC doesn't even sing live, had a famous encounter in a public toilet, and uses autotune yet gets made out to be Mother Teresa because she got cheated on and got bitten by a mosquito, while Jackie gets made out to be in the same league as Helen Mirren, Judi Dench and Anjelica Huston despite the fact she's to acting what CC is to singing(if this wasn't the case and she was a talented actress, JW would've done what her on-screen son, Stefan Dennis or Chris Eccleston did and left sooner to do other roles in America/films/other TV shows, rather than stay in a soap opera for 17 years and end up having to be interviewed by Eamonn Holmes)
Originally Posted by jackbell:
“Who's Jackie Woodburn?”
“Who's Jackie Woodburn?”
she plays susan kennedy in neighbours and even after that long clarification above. i still don't see how she would be a relevant x factor judge or why she would be compared to cheryl cole.
it takes all sorts.
Why every year is there a discussion about the judges? Who cares about which judge is there . Cheryl who? Is that the judge who put Cher and Katie through, at the expense of better singers, is that the judge who didn't spend any time with"her acts"because she was so busy trying to promote her own career, is that the Cheryl people are talking about?.
Originally Posted by imrightok:
“Why every year is there a discussion about the judges? Who cares about which judge is there . Cheryl who? Is that the judge who put Cher and Katie through, at the expense of better singers, is that the judge who didn't spend any time with"her acts"because she was so busy trying to promote her own career, is that the Cheryl people are talking about?.”
“Why every year is there a discussion about the judges? Who cares about which judge is there . Cheryl who? Is that the judge who put Cher and Katie through, at the expense of better singers, is that the judge who didn't spend any time with"her acts"because she was so busy trying to promote her own career, is that the Cheryl people are talking about?.”
The show is more about the judges than the contestants, so I'd say quite a lot of people care.
Originally Posted by anactoria:
“The show is more about the judges than the contestants, so I'd say quite a lot of people care.”
“The show is more about the judges than the contestants, so I'd say quite a lot of people care.”
and thats why the show is beginning to struggle in the ratings. Yes its still the most watched TV programme but its viewing figures are falling. Look at xf USA its no where as popular as American idol. Its supposed to be about the singers, if they want to big up the judges then create a show just for them.
2 of 2
