There seems to be a big divide on these threads of people defending Tulisa and Kelly so who is your favourite female judge or do you like both or none?!
Tulisa fan/Kelly fan
.
Originally Posted by kieranyeah123:
“There seems to be a big divide on these threads of people defending Tulisa and Kelly so who is your favourite female judge or do you like both or none?!”
“There seems to be a big divide on these threads of people defending Tulisa and Kelly so who is your favourite female judge or do you like both or none?!”
I've prefered Tulisa since the start of the live shows - before then...Kelly was doing alright.
But since then there defoes is a Louis/Tulisa and Kelly/Gary divide that I think will grow.
I take the Louis/Tulisa side in that whilst they can make mistakes (Rock week! (even though I think Tulisa's acts got away with it more than other acts did by singing ballads)) they seem pretty decent and Louis especially is keeping the show afloat atm.
Kelly on the other hand is overly aggressive and alongside Gary a bit stuck up about everything. Kelly is certainly the worse of the two - her treatment of Louis has been a disgrace.
I think we can see though that Louis and Tulisa get on really well, whilst Kelly and Gary...have no real chemistry beyond being similarly unlikable and unfair in their mistreatment of Louis - so for me there the ones to go next year.
Tulisa fan I'd say, even if I don't like her 100% (I have big problems with the other two in N-dubz)
Not exactly a fan of anyone but Tulisa is genuine and willing to engage, Kelly is high and mighty in her attitude and condesending at best. Rowlands treatment of Louis is uncalled for and she seems to get off on putting him down all the time. Until the live sessions the video editing hid all this. They started off as equal in my eyes but Tulisa is the only one to still be credibile.
Strangely, I think Louis has done well once the live session's started. As to Gary, I'm lieing to you Barlow, he has hit the underfloor in my expectations.
Strangely, I think Louis has done well once the live session's started. As to Gary, I'm lieing to you Barlow, he has hit the underfloor in my expectations.
Hate Kelly's accent, the way she speaks down to the other judges, her crap work ethic and generally just the way she acts.
Tulisa have supported from the start, knew what I'd get with her and she's stayed true to who she is. This is what she's wanted from day 1 and she's got it (not exactly aspiring to be judge on X Factor, just TV) and she knew how to get it and has worked damn hard to get it, so passing on that experience to the contestants brings back what X Factor SHOULD be like.. but she also adds controversy!
Tulisa have supported from the start, knew what I'd get with her and she's stayed true to who she is. This is what she's wanted from day 1 and she's got it (not exactly aspiring to be judge on X Factor, just TV) and she knew how to get it and has worked damn hard to get it, so passing on that experience to the contestants brings back what X Factor SHOULD be like.. but she also adds controversy!
