Originally Posted by Chris2387:
“Simon always does crap like that. The man is out of touch with music and has always used songs past contestants had a moment with. I think all of Leona's song choices came from songs Simon heard Kelly Clarkson and Katharine McPhee sing on Idol”
Mhm. Although I think Leona's "Summertime" is the best version on these shows (Fantasia a close second, and Ruth and Naima both good), it's not surprising that her two other top performances were somewhat inspired choices: "Chiquitita" and "Could It Be Magic?".
Also, don't forget "Billie Jean": Mere months after David Cook won (and did that song for Top 10 week), Simon used the exact same arrangement for Austin Drage. Personally, I actually liked Austin's performance of it (possibly because that tight shirt was arm porn <3) but I thought he didn't a decent job. Does *not* change the fact though that he loves ripping-off moments and making everyone cover the same thing if he could.