Astro
Chris Rene
Marcus Canty
The Stereo Hogzz
inTENsity
Lakoda Rayne
LeRoy Bell
Stacy Francis
Josh Krajcik
Rachel Crow
Drew
Melanie Amaro

Caitlin. Oh, that's right, she didn't even get through Judges' Houses. In which case .... Josh.

Lakoda Rayne, inTENsity and Josh.

It's pretty early still, but per category:

GIRLS: Drew (overall fave) >> Melanie >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Rachel
BOYS: Marcus/Chris > Astro (dig all 3)
OVERS: Josh > LeRoy >>>> Stacy (no longer hate her, but she is cuckoo)
GROUPS: InTENsity/The Stereo Hogzz >>>>>>>>>> Lakoda Rayne (zzzz)

I'm wondering who's going to be used as fodder for the first B2/elimination? My money's on either LeRoy or Lakoda Rayne. The country vote could keep them safe for a couple of weeks though. It's a difficult call there. LeRoy is an underdog, but that may not matter very much. Should be an interesting vote for sure!

More than happy with any of the boys being thrown under the bus. Really didn't take to any of them.

Drew definately.

Girls- Drew
Overs- Josh <3 <3 (Favourite)
Groups- InTENsity (Don't like any groups, best of the them all)
Boys- My favourite boy was eliminated because LA is a ****ing clown, don't like any others.

Astro! But I respect Drew's talent.

Here are the latests YouTube stats on their 1st live performances

1) Drew - 612,088
2) Astro - 578,366
3) Melanie - 461,760
4) Rachel - 317,544
5) Chris - 288,036
6) Josh - 273,148
7) Stacy - 226,398
8) Marcus - 226,042
9) Lakoda Rayne - 189,851
10) LeRoy - 185,614
11) Stereo Hoggz - 176,660
12) InTENsity - 103,968

I hate Drew's smile. /shallow

I like Melanie, InTENsity, Stereo Hogzz (the lead singer is SEX), Josh, and Astro.

I don't get Chris Rene. His style is too dated.

All the boys are poor and Astro is downright horrible. He isn't a singer. Rap is a different thing and IMO should not be in X Factor. Was bad enough with Cher Lloyd annoying the UK with it thinking she was the second coming, he's worse.

The overs is the strongest category. There isn't anyone weak in it, and 2 are truly exceptional.

The groups: Intensity is so obviously the producer going 'let's do Glee'. They are so sugary there should be a warning for any diabetics (half of USA) watching. The other 2 are ok but not incredibly so.

The girls: 2 are exceptional, 1 is a very irritating Shirley Temple type. Simon never overestimates the taste of the public and is going all guns 'cute kids' plus pretend callback Melanie, whose story he's rigged to make her look like an underdog rather than one of the clear favourites.

Brian Friedman on producing the acts is doing as bad a job as he did in London. Just let them sing instead of all this naff, cheesey choreography or downright baffling bad dancers leaping around like a cheap and very dated Paris show . It's embarrassing.

Josh Drew and Melaine for me the boys haven't impressed me much yet - liked inTENsity at jh but not on live.

Anyone know when next live is? Watched live stream last week and really enjoyed it tho I walked about with bags under my eye the next day
Last edited by wingsofadove : 31-10-2011 at 17:34

Drew by far although i do like Astro, Lakoda Rayne and Stacy too

astro?:sleep:

Paige

It's easier to say who I don't like as I think there are some pretty strong contenders in all the groups.

However, Josh is my overall fave and would happily vote for him if I could.

josh all the way for me

Drew is incredible given she is only 14 - she has to be doing that Delores O'Riordan thing with her voice naturally, unbelieveable really. Melanie has a good range but is lacking in the bass department which makes her although in tune a bit shrieky (think too much treble and not enough bass on a car radio). Listen to her x-factor whitney number on youtube for example. She is still fantastic though.

Drew, she has the X Factor!

Melanie
Josh
Stacy
Leroy
Stereo Hoggz
Drew

, in that order. Liked Drew most at the beginning, but the fact that she can't hold a note is starting to bug me big time. Just listen her, everytime she goes for high, the voice annoingly just cuts out. Josh and Melanie have the best voices.

Melanie Amaro and Stacy Francis for me, in that order..

Astro. Can't stand that awful Stacy crybaby Francis.

Josh.

Melanie.

dont get the drew love, reminds me of janet

Drew.

Then Melanie.

There are a number of talented acts, but I voted inTENsity just for the novelty of it- makes a chane from the endless 4 or 5 person boybands and girlbands that are always on X Factor