Originally Posted by Steve Williams:
“I'm sure it's a very well made and moving programme in its own way but you can hardly refuse to accept any criticism of it because of its subject matter. The only thing wrong with referring to the rating as "poor" is that ratings like that are par for the course at 7.30 on Channel Five.
As has been said, C5 have put it in probably the worst slot imaginable so if the ratings are low then it's hardly entirely the fault of soap-addled viewers ignoring it, it's just as much the fault of the channel. BBC1 have shown things like this at 9pm and pulled in decent audiences.
Kudos to C5 for doing it, but we can't just go easy on it because it's about World War I. You may as well disregard all criticism of Sing If You Can because it raised money for charity.”
It's a half-hour programme, where else could they have scheduled it?
I'm not disregarding all criticism, I just don't think that was very well put. It was bordering on insensitive.
And you know as well as I do that viewers are probably 10 times as likely to watch such a programme on BBC One. But they don't appear to be doing all that much to mark it this year, nor the other major commercial channels, at least not in primetime. So yes, kudos to Channel 5.