Originally Posted by The Difference:
“It's worth pointing out that John Rawling hasn't appeared on talkSPORT since the 2010 World Cup. Deviating away from the topic in hand but I thought at the time (and more so now) that it was strange decision to call upon someone who had done little for the station and nothing since as their third choice commentator (i.e. not as a lead voice like John Roder was at Euro 2012) at that World Cup when they could have used someone else who is more familiar to the talkSPORT listeners and works hard for the station all year round. Wouldn't have been what I'd have done but then I'm not Moz Dee.
Presuming they don't bring in a commentator with no previous connection to the station as a one-off, I think the leading contenders to call next Saturday's fight are Graham Beecroft, who as you say commentated on a few bouts in the early years of talkSPORT; Dom McGuinness, who has reported on boxing for the station, hosts a boxing show on SportsTonightLive and commentated on a few fights for Nuts TV of all channels; or Andy Clarke, who was a reporter for the station for 11 years and is now a football and boxing commentator for Sky Sports.
I agree with your assessment of the fight Steve, it certainly isn't one I'd dream of paying to watch, it has been treated as somewhat of a freak show in the press and I doubt Radio 5 Live will be too disappointed not to be broadcasting it. What with talkSPORT running devoted cricket, golf and Olympic Games shows this summer, I guess this might be a case of Moz Dee trying out different sports-based themes on the station to see which ones prove popular and receive good feedback from the listeners. Given the varying costs of rights, the necessity of doing transcontinental OBs and the times at which fights take place, I personally doubt that talkSPORT will start covering live fights on a regular basis. But should their coverage receive decent feedback, perhaps the boxing segment Gareth A. Davies currently does for Extra Time may get more prominence on the station.”
can't disagree with anything here. . as a big boxing fan who listened to most of the fights TS covered, I'd welcome more coverage on the station. they actually went in for boxing in a reasonably big way at one point, covering regular domestic fights (the kind of thing you now see on Friday and Saturday night fight night on sky) as well as some big fights such as Lennox Lewis world title fights. in fact, in 1999, the covered the 2 Lewis Holyfield fights. they also covered Mike Tyson's first fight in the UK against Julius Frances. Beaky amused me somewhat during the 4 minutes or so the fight lasted by feeling the need to point out that the referee, (who also had the surname frances) wasn't a relation of the fighter winning the prize for most obvious comment of the night in the process. generally, I enjoyed the coverage they provided, although they did have an anoying habit of the summeriser providing in-fight analysis as happens on tv. on 5live, the analysis takes place at the end of a round so you don't miss any of the action.
with the fight not being shown on sky, I wonder if they might bring in a sky commentator for the fight? also, in terms of pundits, Steve Collins has worked for them in the past and I wonder if they'll bring him in.
I'm glad they are covering it-- as you say, its rightly being treated as a freak show but I can't help finding it strangely fascination. one definete listener to TS on July 14th.