According to the Sun newspaper she has apologised to Derry in a letter. So should she stay or should she go?
Should Kitty be kicked out of X factor for her RACIST comments against Derry
1 of 4
Stay.
Let the public decide. If Kitty gets the votes on Saturday she stays if she doesn't (and they save the other act) she goes.
Thats what they usually say on American Idol when scandals happen.
Let the public decide. If Kitty gets the votes on Saturday she stays if she doesn't (and they save the other act) she goes.
Thats what they usually say on American Idol when scandals happen.
Originally Posted by AJ3:
“She should be literally kicked out and hung up to dry like a government mule”
“She should be literally kicked out and hung up to dry like a government mule”
Ah, I smell what you're cookin'
Originally Posted by barrcode88:
“Nope, unproven.”
“Nope, unproven.”
Just like it was with Misha but you still laid into her a lot.
Originally Posted by hitnmix:
“Just like it was with Misha but you still laid into her a lot.”
“Just like it was with Misha but you still laid into her a lot.
”
Yeah well...uhh...
Originally Posted by barrcode88:
“Yeah well...uhh...”
“Yeah well...uhh...
”
Yer well this is what you call Karma
Misha fans got it all by many Kitty fans as well as other and now the tables have turned.
Most of us have been in a position of saying something offensive to another person in the heat of an argument, only to deeply regret it later. Quite often those offensive comments are made to someone we love very much.
Kitty absolutely should not have said that and Derry had every right to be offended, but unless anything else surfaces, this is not evidence that Kitty is a racist.
Stupid and offensive - yes
Racist - no
Should Kitty be kicked off the show - no
Should Derry accept Kitty's apology - yes (maybe he has and I'm behind on the news?)
Kitty absolutely should not have said that and Derry had every right to be offended, but unless anything else surfaces, this is not evidence that Kitty is a racist.
Stupid and offensive - yes
Racist - no
Should Kitty be kicked off the show - no
Should Derry accept Kitty's apology - yes (maybe he has and I'm behind on the news?)
I'd kick nobody out except the producers who keep orchestrating this crap. We really don't know the truth of this episode, and with the fiXFactor it's bound to be murky and orchestrated for publicity.
The team this year has managed to persuade everyone that Janet was going to be kidnapped (for votes of course) so any threat to the chosen one's coronation is gonna get it with both barrels. Remember that they tried to knife Flat cardle last year when they realised that the GBP wanted him to win over the anointed one.
The team this year has managed to persuade everyone that Janet was going to be kidnapped (for votes of course) so any threat to the chosen one's coronation is gonna get it with both barrels. Remember that they tried to knife Flat cardle last year when they realised that the GBP wanted him to win over the anointed one.
Originally Posted by buckybadger:
“Most of us have been in a position of saying something offensive to another person in the heat of an argument, only to deeply regret it later. Quite often those offensive comments are made to someone we love very much.
Kitty absolutely should not have said that and Derry had every right to be offended, but unless anything else surfaces, this is not evidence that Kitty is a racist.
Stupid and offensive - yes
Racist - no
Should Kitty be kicked off the show - no
Should Derry accept Kitty's apology - yes (maybe he has and I'm behind on the news?)”
“Most of us have been in a position of saying something offensive to another person in the heat of an argument, only to deeply regret it later. Quite often those offensive comments are made to someone we love very much.
Kitty absolutely should not have said that and Derry had every right to be offended, but unless anything else surfaces, this is not evidence that Kitty is a racist.
Stupid and offensive - yes
Racist - no
Should Kitty be kicked off the show - no
Should Derry accept Kitty's apology - yes (maybe he has and I'm behind on the news?)”
Totally agree!. Whatever went on Kitty has apologised end of story. As you said everyone has said something that don't mean in a heated argument, should we all lose our jobs?
She appologised for the argument not rasism which she denies.
Trouble is she is unpopular with some and Derry is 'fit', so if he went whinning to producers or Tulisa who made sure it got into the tabliods Derry is more likely to be believed.
Sounds to me like Tulisa's lot are a very sensitive, precious bunch. Last week one or all of them were being victimised by Mishca, then tiny totts or whatever the second worst girl group on XFactor were sobbing over comments that they went looking for, now poor little Derry is a victim of Kitty.
They need to get over themsleves, if they put more energy into the music they might be better than they are.
Trouble is she is unpopular with some and Derry is 'fit', so if he went whinning to producers or Tulisa who made sure it got into the tabliods Derry is more likely to be believed.
Sounds to me like Tulisa's lot are a very sensitive, precious bunch. Last week one or all of them were being victimised by Mishca, then tiny totts or whatever the second worst girl group on XFactor were sobbing over comments that they went looking for, now poor little Derry is a victim of Kitty.
They need to get over themsleves, if they put more energy into the music they might be better than they are.
Originally Posted by paralax:
“She appologised for the argument not rasism which she denies.
Trouble is she is unpopular with some and Derry is 'fit', so if he went whinning to producers or Tulisa who made sure it got into the tabliods Derry is more likely to be believed.
Sounds to me like Tulisa's lot are a very sensitive, precious bunch. Last week one or all of them were being victimised by Mishca, then tiny totts or whatever the second worst girl group on XFactor were sobbing over comments that they went looking for, now poor little Derry is a victim of Kitty.
They need to get over themsleves, if they put more energy into the music they might be better than they are.”
“She appologised for the argument not rasism which she denies.
Trouble is she is unpopular with some and Derry is 'fit', so if he went whinning to producers or Tulisa who made sure it got into the tabliods Derry is more likely to be believed.
Sounds to me like Tulisa's lot are a very sensitive, precious bunch. Last week one or all of them were being victimised by Mishca, then tiny totts or whatever the second worst girl group on XFactor were sobbing over comments that they went looking for, now poor little Derry is a victim of Kitty.
They need to get over themsleves, if they put more energy into the music they might be better than they are.”
Good post
I wonder if big mouth will mention it on Saturday night... seeing as she couldn't help herself Re Misha and due to her defending her comments, she should do...
Originally Posted by Stewie_C:
“I'd kick nobody out except the producers who keep orchestrating this crap. We really don't know the truth of this episode, and with the fiXFactor it's bound to be murky and orchestrated for publicity.
The team this year has managed to persuade everyone that Janet was going to be kidnapped (for votes of course) so any threat to the chosen one's coronation is gonna get it with both barrels. Remember that they tried to knife Flat cardle last year when they realised that the GBP wanted him to win over the anointed one.”
“I'd kick nobody out except the producers who keep orchestrating this crap. We really don't know the truth of this episode, and with the fiXFactor it's bound to be murky and orchestrated for publicity.
The team this year has managed to persuade everyone that Janet was going to be kidnapped (for votes of course) so any threat to the chosen one's coronation is gonna get it with both barrels. Remember that they tried to knife Flat cardle last year when they realised that the GBP wanted him to win over the anointed one.”
Spot on Kitty and Johnny are targets to destroy in the publics mind. Just a shame mud sticks and very unfair. Perhaps next year (if X Factor is around) they'll have even less talent applying.
Originally Posted by yohinnchild:
“I wonder if big mouth will mention it on Saturday night... seeing as she couldn't help herself Re Misha and due to her defending her comments, she should do...”
“I wonder if big mouth will mention it on Saturday night... seeing as she couldn't help herself Re Misha and due to her defending her comments, she should do...”
Yes this will be very telling and so far her complete absense of comment says much in favour of Kitty. Would Tulisa miss the chance if there was any real evidence of sticking it to Kitty?
I don't see it as being racist.
Its a just an insult, she could easily have used "fat" or "short arse" or "4 eyed" and it wouldn't have caused an headlines at all.
As for Derry, well if his mother is a single parent, then what Kitty said would just be a statement of fact.
Its a just an insult, she could easily have used "fat" or "short arse" or "4 eyed" and it wouldn't have caused an headlines at all.
As for Derry, well if his mother is a single parent, then what Kitty said would just be a statement of fact.
She didn't discriminate against him because of his race.
She said his skin colour in an angry sentence. Which she probably shouldn't have and the b word I find more offensive.
Funny how it happened in the house and yet we all know about it. Perhaps Derry is threatened by Kitty's talent and decided to create another media frenzy. Let's face it it's the only thing he'll get publicity for this year.
She said his skin colour in an angry sentence. Which she probably shouldn't have and the b word I find more offensive.
Funny how it happened in the house and yet we all know about it. Perhaps Derry is threatened by Kitty's talent and decided to create another media frenzy. Let's face it it's the only thing he'll get publicity for this year.
1 of 4
