Telling Louis off and then saying the only ingredient missing is the vocals - haha

Did you not actually listen to what she was saying! She said he needs to be able to sing but it is wrong to tell someone what they CANNOT do! I actually agree with her.

i dont get it... if your on about Kelly she as an amazing voice!

I think what Kelly was trying to say was be positive in your criticism, rather than negative. Rather than tell Frankie what he isn't, tell him what he is and what he needs to work on. I think.

I think what she was upset about was him saying 'You will never be...' Her whole work ethic and ethos is that if you work hard enough, want it enough and are willing to do whatever it takes, anybody can do anything, so I think that's all she was calling him on.

How was it hypocrisy?

Agree with Perdita, Louis wa really harsh with his comments and is a sulky little brat at times. I understand what Kelly was saying- she was being very empathic and trying to make the point that if someone wants something enough then they need to work on it

Thats ok but do you really think he can sing? For this stage in the competition you shouldn't be advising the contestant to get singing lessons

I like Kelly. She doesn't resort to personal insults to make her point. I think Gary was wrong to tell Louis to shut up = Louis is probably old enough to be his father.

There is no point in being positive about him, he has no singing talent whatsoever.

Well, I think Kelly was right. It's a bit mean telling anyone they'll never have a career in what they want to. Granted, Frankie's a bit rubbish and (much as I loved them) he's been responsible for Jedward and Wagner.

WAGNER.

Really?

It wasn't; I don't think they could have heard what Kelly was saying. What she objected to was Louis saying - you'll never be a rock star. Some people just don't listen and some arn't discerning enough to understand what's being said.

I still find it hypocracy. Just because he wants be a rock star doesn't mean he will be. You have to have some sort of singing ability. He just talks through songs.