Sticking the knife into Kitty for her dancing, yet expects us to then vote for Frankie. Putting Louis down at every opportunity. He was never this nasty when he was giving interview to Smash Hits back in the days. Did Robbie jumping ship change him?

He is RIGHT about Kitty...
Louis Walsh talks a load of Nonsense (most of the time).

What do you want him to do Lie...And then you would come on here saying " I dont like gary barlow because he is to nice to the contestants"..

The judges cant seem to win this year

He's been bigging up Frankie as if he were Elvis since the live finals kicked off, do you call that honest???!

Hey, let's have less of the "little" thank you.
Louis is the man tonight

I have never seen Gary like this if he is trying to be Cowell he is way off the mark. He was just angry and unpleasant all night.

Given Craigs laclk of mobility, anf Frankies lack of, well, everything, saying Johnny was making a mockery of the show and kitty cannot dance was anything but honest.

agree. Kitty gave it a go and shouldn't have been humiliated for trying to make a real performance (as ever) out of it. Cheapened Gary to be unnecessarily nasty and irrelevant.

It was Dance Night...both Louis contestants did what they were supposed to do....Johnny can not do it any other way but camp and they knew that when the theme was decided...The only one that can truely dance is Marcus and it was set up to give him the edge. He is the chosen one now. Gary was horrible to everyone, as if they were to blame for the theme.

Must admit I am not liking Gary as a judge, finding him to harsh and in some respects very cruel in what he says!

Is he really 75 years old or does he just act it?

He's too harsh - Simon was like a cuddly uncle in comparison to cold, uncaring Gary Barlow.

Liked Gary in the auditions stage but generally not as a judge on the main show. He comes across as nasty sometimes and was a knob tonight.

Garys been horrible since he became a judge, just miserable, and quite honestly harsh!

There are loads of X factor contestants past and present that cannot dance. Gary is one nasty obnoxious, odious little man. I had no idea he could be like this, has he always been arrogant!?

I liked him at the start. Now I'm really beginning to doubt everything he says.

well he thinks booing Frankie is disgusting,,,lol

He was right about Kitty. He still told her she had great vocals - but I actually noticed when she was performing that she's not a natural dancer. He was totally correct.

I agree.

Not a huge fan of Simon Cowell but Simon is always very dignified-something Barlow isn't.

I'm actually starting to wonder what really went on years ago in Take That making Robbie Williams so bitter towards Barlow for so long.

Gary lost all respect IMO when he lied that Frankie was good .Frankie is dire and we all know it ,he knows it , gary knows it everyone knows it .

oh dear poor little kKity got told that she couldnt dance and it the end of the world and Gray a mean nasty man.

The irony is you are slagging Gary down a lot worse than what he said to Kitty. lol

I have always disliked Gary. I have said it before and I will say it again, if Frankie wasn't Gary's act then he would HATE him!

Do you honestly think no judge has ever lied about how good there acts were?

Louis with Jedward and Wagner for a start.

He's right to tell it as he sees it. Sugar coating it for these wannabes merely to be kind and to make them (and most of you lot) like him more is doing nobody any favours.

Barlow does seem a rather grumpy and unpleasant little man.

Neither is Craig but I notice that he didn't mention that.