Well you're a Robbie Fan....But Robbie was in his own words:

"I didn't realize how spiteful and vindictive i could be...I was relentless and just kept at it"

Yeah great guy

I wouldnt say his career came to a halt, but he is not suited to being a judge, he should stick to songwriting which he is amazing at

yeah he was young under loads of pressure and has changed now

I hope you haven't got a mirror on the ceiling.

He had a couple of small solo hits, while Robbie was number one. Songwriting is what he is good at but so is Robbie William's writing partner, who stays out of sight....

He messed up frankie this week by giving him the worst song of all time.

Frankie is so arrogant it is so hard not to hate him.

His performance last night was pure kareoke.

I still can't believe that Garry chose to save him over James in week 1.

Garry knows that Frankie is terrible.

sorry didnt mean garys songs, he writes for a lot of other perfomers

I agree...He's matured and grown from his mistakes...Gary too admitted how they let him down but The fact still stands that Rob fueled the fire the media started...Ya know that disgusting hate campaign in the late 90's that ruined Gary's solo career and got so bad he had to leave the country/fell into depression, and finally was given the respect he deserved with the biggest comeback ever...Meanwhile Karma caught up with Rob who became the joke that Gary used to be...All cause the media are fickle and the audience even more so.

And even when the boys tried to move on...Robbie couldn't shut up for 10 years with his nastiness...Being their friend one minute...Sticking the knife in the next, and when Robbie was at a low ebb...instead of putting the boot in like Robbie deserved and like Robbie did and would do...Gary and the boys opened their arms to him and helped him, and gave him friendship and a renewed lease of life.

And after all that Gary is a nasty piece of work...LMFAO Anyone that can forgive that utter vileness and move forward is a saint...But of course X-Factor is gospel

Almost as vile as Frankie

It balanced out,because,while Gary was exceptionally harsh about her not-very-bad dancing,he was exceptionally kind about her not-very-good vocal.

As Davina would say, it's all panto.

Well, someone call the Nobel committee.

Well Obama got one...Anythings possible

I was so looking forward to Gary being an X Factor judge but he has been so disappointing.

I'd like to see his smug face if Craig and Marcus left tonight and he was left with Frankie as his only remaining act.

I don't think you have the right to judge and make sweeping statements. You were not there and dont know Robbie or Gary personally. He left/was pushed out of TT an alcoholic and drug addict and no one seemed to care or notice. Really interesting interview Robbie and Gary did in Sweden last year after the comeback- where they both admit their faults. It takes alot of pain to hate so much btw.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fjur5x1Nw3M

I agree..Robbie was hurting...No hate without love....And i mentioned Gary/the boys part in it in my post...But the rest is not a sweeping statement...Everything i mentioned happened after the band...The evidence is everywhere...Google is your friend..evidence speaks for itself.

After those comments to LM and trying clearly to upset Tulisa, its official, Barlow is a deluded, spiteful T**T.

He's a horrible man. When Simon would criticise an act he would say it in a way that was funny. He never got personal. Gary is just mean and trying too hard to be like him but hes not. . He was really rude to Louis last week.