I think he should bring the lad back he booted out because of the wrong song choice. I do apologise forgot his name.
If they bring Johnny back he aint going to win
Originally Posted by herejohno:
“I think he should bring the lad back he booted out because of the wrong song choice. I do apologise forgot his name.”
“I think he should bring the lad back he booted out because of the wrong song choice. I do apologise forgot his name.”
...wouldn't really be very fair though,would it ?
I agree! Johnny was just there for entertainment, he had a good voice without all the gimmicks and routines but Louis would of course keep on giving them to him. 
Everybody knows he's not going to win. For the likes of Johnny it's not about winning it's about exposure. So bring him back, and let him have a couple of more weeks of showing us what he can do.
He seems likely a genuinely pleasant chap to me, and I wish him a long career in panto/cabarete or whatever else he fancies!
He seems likely a genuinely pleasant chap to me, and I wish him a long career in panto/cabarete or whatever else he fancies!
Originally Posted by Jackiebo:
“Everybody knows he's not going to win. For the likes of Johnny it's not about winning it's about exposure. So bring him back, and let him have a couple of more weeks of showing us what he can do.
He seems likely a genuinely pleasant chap to me, and I wish him a long career in panto/cabarete or whatever else he fancies!”
“Everybody knows he's not going to win. For the likes of Johnny it's not about winning it's about exposure. So bring him back, and let him have a couple of more weeks of showing us what he can do.
He seems likely a genuinely pleasant chap to me, and I wish him a long career in panto/cabarete or whatever else he fancies!”
Did you vote to save him?
As JackieBo said the further Johnny gets the better it will be for him after the competition ends. Plus I doubt the producers want whoever returns to win (it would made the judges look stupid etc.) so Johnny is probably the best option.
Having said that, if he does return I am pretty sure he will be safe this week, maybe being bottom two the following week.
Having said that, if he does return I am pretty sure he will be safe this week, maybe being bottom two the following week.
I really hope they do not bring him back. yes he can sing, but he is at best pantomine worthy. He could also end up being another act where everyone supports the underdog and they vote to save him right through to the final, which to be honest he doesn't deserve, as there are better acts than him.
Originally Posted by NightFalls:
“Did you vote to save him?”
“Did you vote to save him?”
Nope! Haven't voted in any of these competions ever. Would feel like a bit of a fool if I had voted for Frankie at the weekend tho'.....
Does this make my opinion less valid?
Johnny may not look like a typical pop star, but he's the sort who would make a very nice career out of his X Factor exposure. A bit of telly, a bit of panto, gigs at gay prides, a nice gig on a cruise ship somewhere sunny.
Oh, he'll do very well out of this. He'll probably make more money than the eventual winner.
Oh, he'll do very well out of this. He'll probably make more money than the eventual winner.
Johnny will win if he comes back
after he was unfairly sent home by the judges !!
they should have not done a double elimination !!
after he was unfairly sent home by the judges !! they should have not done a double elimination !!
The thing is if they bring Johnny back and one of the other acts go home because of him cant see people liking that , I just think they should let public decide thats my opnion.
Originally Posted by actually:
“Johnny will win if he comes back after he was unfairly sent home by the judges !!
they should have not done a double elimination !!”
“Johnny will win if he comes back
after he was unfairly sent home by the judges !! they should have not done a double elimination !!”
But if he was as popular as people on here make him out to be he wouldn't have been in the bottom 3 - more people would have voted, thus he would have been safe. He wouldn't have been in the sing-off. Also we don't know who had the highest number of votes out of him and Kitty. So even if it had been the normal sing off between two acts with one elimination it might have been between him and The Risk so he might have ended up getting the boot anyway.
Olly Murs was in the bottom 2 the week Jedward went in 2009. He was actually bottom as well but was kept by the judges.
Therefore....if Johnny was to return, he could easily go a lot further.
Therefore....if Johnny was to return, he could easily go a lot further.
I love how some people are fishing for reasons why their favourite should be brought back but not Johnny who may not even have been out had it not been a double elimination. I doubt he was in the bottom two.
Originally Posted by Sez_babe:
“Olly Murs was in the bottom 2 the week Jedward went in 2009. He was actually bottom as well but was kept by the judges.
Therefore....if Johnny was to return, he could easily go a lot further.”
“Olly Murs was in the bottom 2 the week Jedward went in 2009. He was actually bottom as well but was kept by the judges.
Therefore....if Johnny was to return, he could easily go a lot further.”
G4, JLS and Ray were bottom two as well and made the final like Olly.
Originally Posted by Candy Store:
“G4, JLS and Ray were bottom two as well and made the final like Olly.”
“G4, JLS and Ray were bottom two as well and made the final like Olly.”
Olly was the only one I remembered but yeh that's good then.
I think no one who's won it has ever been in the bottom 2 have they?
Op the lad you mean is James Michael and I agree with you, he should be the one reinstated, not Johnny. I am sure a lot of the public would not like Johnny to be brought back, he was booted out by the judges being in the bottom 3, all 4 judges voted him off, even his own mentor voted him off, that does not bode well for me, or Johnny come to that, who would want to work again with someone who said you're out.
Originally Posted by Green Goddess:
“Op the lad you mean is James Michael and I agree with you, he should be the one reinstated, not Johnny. I am sure a lot of the public would not like Johnny to be brought back, he was booted out by the judges being in the bottom 3, all 4 judges voted him off, even his own mentor voted him off, that does not bode well for me, or Johnny come to that, who would want to work again with someone who said you're out.”
“Op the lad you mean is James Michael and I agree with you, he should be the one reinstated, not Johnny. I am sure a lot of the public would not like Johnny to be brought back, he was booted out by the judges being in the bottom 3, all 4 judges voted him off, even his own mentor voted him off, that does not bode well for me, or Johnny come to that, who would want to work again with someone who said you're out.”
So why would James want to work with Gary Barlow - his mentor - who said "No your out"
Originally Posted by Jackiebo:
“Nope! Haven't voted in any of these competions ever. Would feel like a bit of a fool if I had voted for Frankie at the weekend tho'.....
Does this make my opinion less valid?”
“Nope! Haven't voted in any of these competions ever. Would feel like a bit of a fool if I had voted for Frankie at the weekend tho'.....
Does this make my opinion less valid?”
So you want him back and yet you are not prepared to save him!!?? You are relying on other people to spend their money voting to save. In that case yes it does make your opinion less valid, but this applies to all the others who are wanting him back, they wouldn't have spent money on him either.
I would never rally for an act to return if i hadn't spent a penny saving him!
