Why not over Misha B as well the Tiggi? as Janet is shed loads better than any of them and for me could win so could Marcus come to that.

Why was Gary doing this for Jason Orange what the hell has he got to do with it, spill the beans please as I have no idea, I dont read the press, and so really am not up to speed on things... no pun intended either..

No offence but James had an ok voice but that was about it. He should of stayed in over Frankie but he is not at the level of Marcus and Craig. That leaves 2shoes and amelia as john jo was a comedy act. I suppose 2shoes will bring fun to the xfactor, but if it was about vocal ability amelia should go through to the live shows

This bloke was dog turd and had the personality of a wet lettuce.

He really was another dud I'm afraid. That said, the series has been full of duds so maybe he should win.

hes getting mine.

We dont all like POWER vocals you know, I like James and he reminds me of other artists I like without sounding like them.. he is not weak, you should try listening to his you tube stuff you may get a shock at how good he actually is.

And limited, no I would not agree with that either, he is pretty versatile and goodness added bonus he can also play guitar which makes him much more credible to me for a start.

Or maybe you pulled that theory out of thin air?

Kelly talked about how much she liked Amelia and even invited her back to the show the following week.

Why can't you leave Amelia's personality out of it? you don't know her.

Even in this 'Vote James' thread, all these anti-Amelia people have to make it all about her personality and get their petty jibes in

"sour-faced" "brat" etc etc.

It just reeks of such bitterness, to say these things about a 16 year old kid they don't even know. Meanwhile those of us who don't want James in, are simply saying we don't rate his talent

Hardly. She's displayed a crappy attitude since her exit from the show, or haven't you been keeping up seeing as how you're such a big fan and all?

Do the show really need another bad brat, as sorry that seems to be what she is, they just got rid of one, and she seemed very fond of him as well,, two peas and all...

And of course the papers always tell the truth

Since when was Jonjo a comedy act!! I don't think so!!

IMO all the ones who got booted the first week were ruined by songs chosen in order to get them out. James shouldn't have gone, Frankie was vocally weaker than he was buy a motorway let alone a mile.

Yes the M1 motorway.

I cannot get over Gary Barlow saying in the press conference that James has a recording voice, then why the hell did he leave him out of the final 3 for a pratt who had no chance of a recording contract, as Frankie basically cannot sing, and was never going to win once they sent him down the route of bad boy out of control.

It beggars belief to even hear Barlow have the audacity to promote James now when he left him out why has he not stood up and been counted saying he made a big big mistake, then maybe I could half forgive him for causing this almighty cock*up in the first place.

I have to say for me this is all dreadful, these people all four acts have been rejected in the most awful manner possible and now they are being asked to do it all over again... because Gary Barlow, mr Knowitall, put the wrong person through in the very first week.

It is not fair on the others either, whoever gets through could be in for a tough 24 hours from some of the others let alone the pressure of having to sing on Saturday. Okay it could be said they are all being given another golden opportunity, well is it really, if they are in for 24 hours only, not only were they rejected week one but they get rejected again and that will stick like mud to them. I want James back, for me he should never have been let go, but even I wonder if this is a right career move for the lad...

Gary and the other 3 judges had no say in who was picked for the final 3, that was all down to the producers.

then they are plain liars are they not, with Tulisa saying she had changed her mind 4 times was it during the actual day, and one other did as well, did Gary say he only made up HIS mind at 5pm what utter liars these people are.

Don't worry I am well aware who calls the shots on this show, his name is Simon Cowell... and his production team. I imagine that is why Barlow is not apologising for putting the wrong guy through, he knows it was not down to him, but if the show wants people to think it was, then Gary has to carry the can... wonder if he would jump at the chance to do this show again, as he has lost all credibility, even more so today saying James has a recording voice, if he thought that he should have fought tooth and nail to put him through in the first place.

How did Frankie get through then?

He was worse than mediocre, but lets face it they wanted a bad lad and James is as far removed from that as you can get...

It is a total shambles, how on earth will people who only ever tuned in to show one make any sense of all of this, and if they do who on earth would they vote for, James was stitched up with the song and the production that night, not a level playing field at all.

They should all be made to sing again, and then let people vote for them, not this stupidity.

where did you see the press conference when Gary said James has a recording voice?

It has been typed up on here word for word, I will try and find you the thread, but it is here.. he said James had a recording voice, Tulisa said something about needing 2 shoes for the fun factor or similar lines. There is a very long thread here over 7 pages you can take a look.

Cheers
ive sent u a PM

It was reported by @dsrealitybites while they were live blogging the x factor press conference earlier. Here's the link to the tweet: https://twitter.com/#!/dsrealitybite...32368022630402

Thank you so much for finding that, I am trying to assist son with his Nazi history A level work, what fun that is.. there are comparisons thought, brain washing springs to mind!

So is this tweet what was said by Gary or not as now I am totally confused I dont know how tweets work really, I thought it was the dialogue from the press conference when the judges plied the public to believe in their acts coming back.. was I wrong.

Even so I also think James has a recording voice, he stands out like Morrison and Merriweather for me and Bruno Mars come to that, in that his voice is unique I would know it was him singing on the radio. Maybe he was too much of a threat to the show.. so he got the chop.

*bump*

just a reminder pick up your phones - his fans I mean and please place a vote for the lad, he should have been there initially, he was robbed by someone who only wanted the fame, not the career, in fact why was he there, he could not even sing, let alone has a recording voice, which Gary says, and rightly so, that James does have.

Don't sit back and moan later, act now and phone.. will get the number added here shortly for him.

Voted for him and hope he wins - somehow I get the feeling Amelia will be a younger version of Kitty on the show, dont think I can stand that..... James will make a refreshing change if he is allowed to play his guitar on stage

Here's the number for anyone yet to vote...

0901 616 1303 – JAMES MICHAEL