I don't hate Amelia and if she had behaved better (and her parents had behaved better) after her leaving I might have voted for her to come back, talented lass.
As it is I will probably vote for James.
As it is I will probably vote for James.
What is with the Amelia Hate?
2 of 4
Originally Posted by gentleguy:
“its not that they hate her they just think its silly that acts have worked hard for weeks and its like just sending in a random person that doesnt need to work hard as others did.”
“its not that they hate her they just think its silly that acts have worked hard for weeks and its like just sending in a random person that doesnt need to work hard as others did.”
Oddly whoever comes back will have to work even harder, they have no fan bases like the others do already, and some people are not going to like this idea no matter who comes back and will boycott voting for them,. so not sure you are right on it being some easy ride.
Originally Posted by donbon:
“She's a threat to people's favs - I honestly think that's why some FMs are reacting the way they are. If she wasn't a real contender to win people wouldn't be attacking her so much.”
“She's a threat to people's favs - I honestly think that's why some FMs are reacting the way they are. If she wasn't a real contender to win people wouldn't be attacking her so much.”
Of course!
It couldn't simply be because people don't like her as a performer, don't like the way she badmouthed the X-Factor or simply don't like the twist itself...could it?
Originally Posted by Green Goddess:
“Oddly whoever comes back will have to work even harder, they have no fan bases like the others do already, and some people are not going to like this idea no matter who comes back and will boycott voting for them,. so not sure you are right on it being some easy ride.”
“Oddly whoever comes back will have to work even harder, they have no fan bases like the others do already, and some people are not going to like this idea no matter who comes back and will boycott voting for them,. so not sure you are right on it being some easy ride.”
Indeed. Now if that returnee went on to win [as unlikely as that is - even Amelia's probable return].
Then it'd get real messy...
James [as much as he bored me at Judges houses] should've been the default choice to bring back I think though.
Originally Posted by Lizzy11268:
“I don't hate Amelia and if she had behaved better (and her parents had behaved better) after her leaving I might have voted for her to come back, talented lass.
As it is I will probably vote for James.”
“I don't hate Amelia and if she had behaved better (and her parents had behaved better) after her leaving I might have voted for her to come back, talented lass.
As it is I will probably vote for James.”
You know Lizzy it is always wise in life to wait and see, never bad mouth something that gave you a chance as you never know whats around the corner, so I fully agree with you, she should have kept her mouth shut and her parents should have as well, they made themselves look mealy mouthed and ungrateful, she said things that make her look big headed and above the others on the show, she could live to regret that, as I am sure we are not the only ones who have read her comments, and seen the press. I will be breaking my code of no votes for this show to actually vote for James as I was totally gutted he did not get through, not this time, I will make the effort otherwise I cannot moan when he does not.
Originally Posted by Selena:
“she behaved like a spoilt little brat over her first exit.”
“she behaved like a spoilt little brat over her first exit.”
And we really should expect better from a (then) sixteen-year-old child. The show pimped her and built her up to such a degree that she was fractionally behind the favourite (Janet), then pulled the red carpet from underneath her.
Whether you like her or not, Amelia has pop star potential - she is one of only 2-3 from this year I can see having any chance of selling records.
I have nothing against her but she's nothing special. At first I got an Allison Iraheta vibe from her but as time went on I really didn't think she was that good, especially on the lives. I'm dreading her inevitable re-entry because she has been overhyped to ridiculous levels.
its not about hate, that is a strong emotion that shouldn't be confused with opinion. people are going to have going to have opinions and concerns after her last exit. i don't hate or rate her. she reminds me to much of pixie lott, only pixie is better.
Originally Posted by Since Yesterday:
“And we really should expect better from a (then) sixteen-year-old child. The show pimped her and built her up to such a degree that she was fractionally behind the favourite (Janet), then pulled the red carpet from underneath her.”
“And we really should expect better from a (then) sixteen-year-old child. The show pimped her and built her up to such a degree that she was fractionally behind the favourite (Janet), then pulled the red carpet from underneath her.”
The shows had sixteen year olds on before and they have behaved maturely. Also Amelia was my favourite girl and even I knew that she would leave that week because she performed weaker than the other girls, so I never understood why she was so suprised that she got voted out in the first place, except she expected to get through on past performances. Also I think that Amelia's parents have acted just as immature and they were just as bad with her older brother on Any Dream Will Do and they are adults, so whats their excuse?
What is with the Amelia Hate?
She's been near Frankie enough said!
One of the most over rated contestants ever her fans remind me of Dannii fans on here, thinking she is some kind of demi god!
She's been near Frankie enough said!
One of the most over rated contestants ever her fans remind me of Dannii fans on here, thinking she is some kind of demi god!
Originally Posted by gpk:
“pixie is better.”
“pixie is better.”
Is it the dire songs that do it for you, or her complete lack of charisma?
Originally Posted by Selena:
“The shows had sixteen year olds on before and they have behaved maturely. Also Amelia was my favourite girl and even I knew that she would leave that week because she performed weaker than the other girls, so I never understood why she was so suprised that she got voted out in the first place, except she expected to get through on past performances. Also I think that Amelia's parents have acted just as immature and they were just as bad with her older brother on Any Dream Will Do and they are adults, so whats their excuse?”
“The shows had sixteen year olds on before and they have behaved maturely. Also Amelia was my favourite girl and even I knew that she would leave that week because she performed weaker than the other girls, so I never understood why she was so suprised that she got voted out in the first place, except she expected to get through on past performances. Also I think that Amelia's parents have acted just as immature and they were just as bad with her older brother on Any Dream Will Do and they are adults, so whats their excuse?”
Who is her brother, sorry did not know this, and if that is the case surely they should have learnt from the mistakes they made if they were immature about that.
I agree on she expected to be through .. you could see it written all over her face, just as it was on Misha B's.
On the other hand you had James who knew he was a goner, which was really sad, and he has bad mouthing nothing or no one, so bring him back.
I dont hate Amelia I just think she has been hyped out the water. Why did they put through Sophie if they really wanted Amelia is what I do not get.
+ she's just yet another little rich kid who gets on the show , because the circles there lifestyles and class bring them into contact with !!!
Girls hate good looking girls.
If it was a guy who said the things she said there wouldn't be half the uproar.
If it was a guy who said the things she said there wouldn't be half the uproar.
Originally Posted by Selena:
“The shows had sixteen year olds on before and they have behaved maturely.
Also Amelia was my favourite girl and even I knew that she would leave that week because she performed weaker than the other girls, so I never understood why she was so suprised that she got voted out in the first place, except she expected to get through on past performances.
Also I think that Amelia's parents have acted just as immature and they were just as bad with her older brother on Any Dream Will Do and they are adults, so whats their excuse?”
“The shows had sixteen year olds on before and they have behaved maturely.
Also Amelia was my favourite girl and even I knew that she would leave that week because she performed weaker than the other girls, so I never understood why she was so suprised that she got voted out in the first place, except she expected to get through on past performances.
Also I think that Amelia's parents have acted just as immature and they were just as bad with her older brother on Any Dream Will Do and they are adults, so whats their excuse?”
Feel free to name them.
She left Sophie for dead, for a start.
Her parents aren't in the competition. Did you have issues with Shayne, because his dad was serving time?
Originally Posted by Timothy Bryce:
“Girls hate good looking girls.
If it was a guy who said the things she said there wouldn't be half the uproar.”
“Girls hate good looking girls.
If it was a guy who said the things she said there wouldn't be half the uproar.”
You might want to search this forum for the words 'credible Matt Cardle'
well at the end of the day she is an amazing vocalist! and thats what the competition needs! an amazing vocalist, therefore she should be put through!
Originally Posted by Too Close:
“What is with the Amelia Hate?
She's been near Frankie enough said!
One of the most over rated contestants ever her fans remind me of Dannii fans on here, thinking she is some kind of demi god!”
“What is with the Amelia Hate?
She's been near Frankie enough said!
One of the most over rated contestants ever her fans remind me of Dannii fans on here, thinking she is some kind of demi god!
”
i have to agree, very overrated on here and some of her fans were horrible about sophie being picked over her. if she gets back on the show i will give her a chance, that`s the objective thing to do. unlike some her fans that are still moaning about sophie.
Originally Posted by rickster1995:
“well at the end of the day she is an amazing vocalist! and thats what the competition needs! an amazing vocalist, therefore she should be put through!”
“well at the end of the day she is an amazing vocalist! and thats what the competition needs! an amazing vocalist, therefore she should be put through!”
I totally agree with you, the best vocalists are Misha B and Craig but I think Amelia is a great addittion because it means the best will be against each other.
For me a Misha B, Amelia Lilly, Marcus/LittleMix final would be a breath of fresh air, as the best will be competiting against each other
I dont hate her - I wanted her to stay originally but I dont think the press attention has done her any favours - basically since she's left the show it's all been about her and frankie, or her/her parents slagging off the show. I just changed my mind a bit from what Ive seen of her since, I reckon she will have gone down it popularity because of what people have read. I do think she's a good singer, she should have been in there from the start no doubt.
Originally Posted by bazztheman93:
“I totally agree with you, the best vocalists are Misha B and Craig but I think Amelia is a great addittion because it means the best will be against each other.
For me a Misha B, Amelia Lilly, Marcus/LittleMix final would be a breath of fresh air, as the best will be competiting against each other”
“I totally agree with you, the best vocalists are Misha B and Craig but I think Amelia is a great addittion because it means the best will be against each other.
For me a Misha B, Amelia Lilly, Marcus/LittleMix final would be a breath of fresh air, as the best will be competiting against each other
”
Yes but that is only your opinion others like myself think James has a wonderful voice, so you cannot expect everyone is going to agree with your choices. I also do not think Misha B is amazing either, she is not for me at all, certainly not a breath of fresh air, I want to leave the room most times she has been on.. last week was her best for me. Marcus however I do think is a breath of fresh air, and could see him winning this show, he is picking up fans left right and centre people who did not rate him week one do now, and I happen to fall into that category.
Originally Posted by MakinItHappen:
“Misha talented? Hah ... oh that wasn't a pun BTW.”
“Misha talented? Hah ... oh that wasn't a pun BTW.”
Obviously...but,to be fair,I suppose when you're used to dealing with people who cannot spot the obvious instead of people who can appreciate things like Misha's talent...
Anyway,I think Amelia deserved to stay longer,and styling/song choice/staging let her down.
2 of 4
