I think its a very win or bust situation for Amelia.

She will get voted back in and if she stays out of the bottom two first time around, I think she will have enough momentum to go on and win it

I think Marcus,Misha,Janet,Craig,Little Mix and Kitty fans might not agree! We're ready for her!!! Bring it on.

If she gets through to saturday and is given a good song I think she will get through this week, and it could be onwards and upwards. I think Kitty will be in the bottom this week along with Misha B, and kitty will leave.

...i really hope she didn't tarnish her rep with her knee tremble in the car park with francis

I am sure she is trying to forget about that but will the audience.

I take it she has never been home to Middlesborough

Agreed absolutely

Depends what happens Sunday. If Amelia or whoever gets picked makes it through and there's a shock bottom two ie. Misha and Marcus, There might be a back lash against them and the twist in general.

I'll be very surprised (and annoyed) if the returning act (Amelia or not) goes on to win.

I disagree.

I think it could easily be a case of surviving this week's bottom two on the back of hype over this new twist and then falling into the bottom two the following week after the hype wears off and the fanbases of other acts start voting more and more.

This.

Out Saturday

She may get back in then Misha B will sit on her.

Yep - I have a feeling that if she a. wins the vote to get into the finals again and b. gets enough votes to carry her through to next weekend - she'll go on and win it

Out on Sunday, then on Monday, telling us all that The Xfactor as once again destroyed her chance of becoming a credible artist;

...if she gets her head between them thighs...amelia's a goner...it'll be like cracking walnuts

Craig wil bitch slap her and ram biscuits down her throat.

And Little Mix will Run and tell Tulisa...

And she'll return to being Frankie's blow-up doll on Big Brother

Not unless Derry gets to them first

So is it confirmed that she is going to replace Frankie? I have been away from the X factor forum for a day so it is catch up

If it is confirmed why is she coming back out of all the contestants? On that first live show she did the worst out of the others - her version of Billy Jean was horrible. So it seems wrong to just shove her back in the competition.