• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Even when Amelia returns is she safe enough to win
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
DUNDEEBOY
10-11-2011
Tall Blonde girl who looks about 25. Is she going to be popular enough with the traditional safe voters. I am not sure she really has that "safe" factor that the voters like people like Joe, Matt, Leon, Craig, Marcus and even Janet all seem like they certainly do
BBFanaticMark
10-11-2011
Nah she'll be first out
Danny699
10-11-2011
I can't stand her.
galena
10-11-2011
Originally Posted by DUNDEEBOY:
“Tall Blonde girl who looks about 25. Is she going to be popular enough with the traditional safe voters. I am not sure she really has that "safe" factor that the voters like people like Joe, Matt, Leon, Craig, Marcus and even Janet all seem like they certainly do”

Is she really tall? I seem to remember Tulisa towered above her when presenting her with the cake - but maybe she was standing on a box or something And hasn't she still got pink hair?
happy tv
10-11-2011
If she gets in, she will be first out. The return of the rejects reeks of injustice to the others who have been in the competition from the beginning and who have proved themselves worthy. People don't like someone to have an unfair advantage. Wait for the big angry face when she is eliminated again. She was so ungracious the first time
syncage
10-11-2011
To stay in the competition her fans (which she has approx 48 hours to rally!) will have to vote first to get her in the show, and then again after the show to keep her there. She is at an immediate disadvantage as she needs to get to lot's of votes to stay on... doesn't really cancel out the whole skipping the last 4/5 weeks though!

I would think it quite likely she might be in saturday and then out sunday... wonder in the producers will give her one week safe from elimination (a la big brother?)
Rotsea Rover
10-11-2011
She might survive this week but I can't see her surviving next week if she does get that far
tomi-08
10-11-2011
No... she's incredibly unlikeable also.
Too Close
10-11-2011
Let's hope we don't get the chance to find out!
Zone_Out
10-11-2011
i laugh if shes voted straight back out the day after
Alicey
10-11-2011
Whoever returns have zero chance of winning or even reaching the final as their presence will just be seen as unfair and they won't get votes.
staceyxxx23
10-11-2011
Don't think she'll win, she'll possibly make the final though.
Satnavvy
10-11-2011
That makeover makes her look like a 40 year old trying to look young!
jdayeh13
10-11-2011
She'll obviously survive the first week. She will automatically stand out with the 'return factor' and she will receive lots of votes automatically. Plus the ones she will most likely recieve for a good performance. However if a popular act (Little Mix, Craig, Marcus, Misha etc.) goes, she will recieve a huge backlash.

Amelia has automatically got into the final 7 and is now on the tour, I think she has received enough of a bonus. She shouldn't win because it is unfair (and I did really like her when she was in the competition).

However, unless its Kitty, I can't see the judges saving her if she is in the bottom two, mainly for the fact that they will have bonded with the acts over the past weeks and will most likely stay "loyal" to them. The only reason she would be saved is so they don't 'lose face'.
NightFalls
10-11-2011
I did like her at the beginning, but once all the nastiness from her and her family emerged i went right off her.
Eve Elle
10-11-2011
Who says she's back in anyhow?
Dan-Bevis
10-11-2011
Originally Posted by Alicey:
“Whoever returns have zero chance of winning or even reaching the final as their presence will just be seen as unfair and they won't get votes.”

This.

There simply won't be enough time for the general public to get to know them [as well as the rest].

X Twitter etc. followers won't amount to much.
jimbojones
10-11-2011
Not with that awful pink hair lol
NightFalls
10-11-2011
Originally Posted by jdayeh13:
“She'll obviously survive the first week. She will automatically stand out with the 'return factor' and she will receive lots of votes automatically. Plus the ones she will most likely recieve for a good performance. However if a popular act (Little Mix, Craig, Marcus, Misha etc.) goes, she will recieve a huge backlash.

Amelia has automatically got into the final 7 and is now on the tour, I think she has received enough of a bonus. She shouldn't win because it is unfair (and I did really like her when she was in the competition).

However, unless its Kitty, I can't see the judges saving her if she is in the bottom two, mainly for the fact that they will have bonded with the acts over the past weeks and will most likely stay "loyal" to them. The only reason she would be saved is so they don't 'lose face'.”

What do you mean unless its Kitty, there are many who like and support her!! Whoever comes back shouldn't be saved over anyone!

She hasn't even been voted back in yet either, a bit presumptious!
RealityReal31
10-11-2011
Originally Posted by NightFalls:
“What do you mean unless its Kitty, there are many who like and support her!!”

No I really like Kitty. But what I mean is if Kitty is in the bottom 2 with Amelia, I can see the Judges giving up on her, considering it is her 3rd time. (I don't want it to happen ofc).
Purple-Kiwis
10-11-2011
That's what's so totally wrong with this twist. It's going to be awkward if they lose the public vote and leave AGAIN. But for them to win would be ridiculous, they've already been identified as rejects.
Patti-Ann
10-11-2011
I guess the big question is, would people rather have Amelia there or Frankie
NightFalls
10-11-2011
Originally Posted by RealityReal31:
“No I really like Kitty. But what I mean is if Kitty is in the bottom 2 with Amelia, I can see the Judges giving up on her, considering it is her 3rd time. (I don't want it to happen ofc).”

Fair enough. I really can't understand why she isn't more popular, she seems lovely and works really hard every week, i would be sad to see her go as i enjoy watching her.
P Barnard
10-11-2011
Originally Posted by BBFanaticMark:
“Nah she'll be first out”

Amilia to win!!
Tortue
10-11-2011
I don't get all the fuss about her. She wasn't good on the first show and I wasn't surprised Kelly got rid of her

Mind you I never saw the auditions and bootcamps etc. Only the live shows.
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map