Seriously, he's so WET! Dreary and ugh ... just comes across as a bit of a wimp, I really don't want him voted back in.

He has the GORGE

I know what you mean. I didn't find him at all unlikable, but he was kind of a drag. I hope he doesn't return. Apart from Jonjo, he'd be my least favourite choice.

Yep, I said as much in another thread.

"I jus wanna gerra house for me mam" boo hoo, whinge whinge.

The guy was a singing sob story.

Yep he's the human personification of the colour beige.

Bland, just bland.

I think 'wet' is the perfect word for him, wet, yes.

I thought he seemed really nice, even if his performance was really awful. Him bursting into tears during the reveal was defo the tearjerking moment of the series.

Wet beats FRANKIE at least.

I liked him but he was dreadful on the first live show. Him and Janet in the same show, I'd rather watch paint dry.

I had to remember who he was - he'd look better without the hat.

Hes lovely, and he deserved a chance..I hope he gets back in!

Agreed OP.

But I'd prefer him over the Sob Soldier even still...

if you mean very bland and average singer at best then yes he is wet



he might be a lovely guy but being a lovely guy doesnt sell records which is ultimately what we/there after.

If theres any justice in this world amelia will be the one voted back in as i beleave she could do well records wise.

However have a horrible feeling the he is so fit begrade will be out in force and itll be james voted back in

if people think he's fit they're blind as anything! His hair! everytime I see a pic I wanna chop it off .......

Perhaps he'd be more likeable if he was promiscuous, a borderline alcoholic, lazy (living off his parents) and a self-confessed druggie!

I thought he came across as a nice lad and thought he had potential.

Incidentally, what's wrong with wanting to buy a house for your family?

personality of a blancmange

Nope I think he is lovely with a lovely voice as well

No. The producers edited so much of James to make him look dull. If you watch his interview on Holy Moly, you'll see that he's bags of fun and genuinely nice.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxzL5Fep9OY
Amelia, on the other hand, can't stop her inner brat from coming out.

he might be a genuinely nice guy but that doesnt mean his singing isnt very average and bland.

I would but I don't like his curly hair much. He would either have to straighten it or shave it off.

I'm sure he's a nice guy, but he's boring. I was bored everytime he opened his mouth to sing from audition to his first live performance.

Amelia may come across as a bitch, but she has potential.

So how did you feel about Frankie

I liked his voice a lot, reminds me a bit of James Morrison or someone, he seems a likeable guy too. I'd be happy if he returned but I think it's definitely gonna be Amelia.

Nothing at all. Agree with your post.

He seems a nice lad, but a bit shy - so what's wrong with that?

I don't think he comes across much different to Marcus or Craig tbh.

No, I think he (like the other boys left in the competition) is humble, sweet and has an absolutely gorgeous voice. Granted he could have a little more charisma but he's probably just a bit shy and there's nothing wrong with that at all.

Yep, said exactly this the moment I clapped eyes on him. A simpering, damp flannel of a boy. Having said that, none of the blokes in the competition are exactly he-men, are they? Even throughout the auditions, there wasn't one single bloke with any balls. All "whoops-a-daisy, I should say so."

Oh, and in the video on the home page where he's sat behind Gary Barlow, he looks like a camp Glenn Quagmire.