She will be of course but clearly they needed something to shake up a fairly diabolical year for talent.

Just supposing she didn't get back in and say James was voted back in.

Would they need another gimmick as that would be the "wrong" result and there would be losing a tabloid act in favour of a very beige act

It really does not matter which of them comes back !! For any act to compete to win in a show half way through the live finals is absolutely ridiculous and a total farce.

Imagine if Jonjo Kerr returned? I think it is very much in the producer's plans to bring back Amelia Lily. Anything else would be a huge shock. Did you know that Amelia is 4th favourite to win with the Bookies and she isn't even in the competition.

I think that it could be to do with the fact that Janet may be failing as a producer plan A. Wouldn't be surprised to see Janet go this week.

I know if is voted back in and survives the first weekend she will likely become favourite to win

The show will never be in 'crisis' because things will always be twisted around so that the viewers are conned into spending money by voting. They don't care who wins, they don't care about anybody's career, it's all about the show and how many fools will pick up their phones and spend money.

no. Amelia is ghastly. Does no-one remember her terrible performance of that Michael Jackson song? shouty, flat, embarrassingly bad. She was the obvious one to leave. As unlikeable as Jonjo.