1 Tulisa
2.Louis
3.kelly
4 gary-too bias on his own acts i mean "that was the performance of the season" a little OTT
2.Louis
3.kelly
4 gary-too bias on his own acts i mean "that was the performance of the season" a little OTT
Results:Who's your favourite judge?
Tulisa
62 (39.74%)
Gary
19 (12.18%)
Louis
47 (30.13%)
Kelly
28 (17.95%)
Voters: 156. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Halfway Point - Favourite Judge
2 of 3
1. Louis - he is exasperating and reminds me of a bitchy old queen most of the time, but even though he's been using his trademark 'fun-factor' cliche for about 5 years now, the sentiment has never been more true this year. Probably the most honest of the bunch this year as well.
2. Tulisa - small fish in a big pond, but the public love a tryer and she really has been trying hard with her groups. From what I've seen she's the hardest working judge this year. If she returns I hope she brushes up on her musical knowledge a bit, and works on her diction (ballid, anyone
).
3. Kelly - I'm not sure if someone has told her to be completely over the top with the American slang, or if that's something of her own invention, but she can be a bit OTT. I often find her quite arrogant, like she's the only professional surrounded by amateurs. Yes she's been in the biz near on 20 years and has had international success, but she in the UK, on a UK show, with three UK judges. Experience and knowledge is great, but not if you're going to rub everyone's noses in it.
4. Gary - As much as I want to like him, I think I've run out of patience. I still respect the guy as an artist and a songwriter, but as a judge, mentor and a personality? Rubbish. He comes across as more interested in himself and using the show as a promotional platform than he is in his acts, most evidently with Frankie. I think a small part of him thought that Frankie would come to his senses and knuckle down if he made it past the first few tentative weeks, and now can't face the reality that had he'd been sterner with the boy, he probably wouldn't have derailed quite so spectacularly. He'd probably blame the other contestants for not attempting to reign Frankie in during their time with him at the house if he thought he could get away with it.
2. Tulisa - small fish in a big pond, but the public love a tryer and she really has been trying hard with her groups. From what I've seen she's the hardest working judge this year. If she returns I hope she brushes up on her musical knowledge a bit, and works on her diction (ballid, anyone
).3. Kelly - I'm not sure if someone has told her to be completely over the top with the American slang, or if that's something of her own invention, but she can be a bit OTT. I often find her quite arrogant, like she's the only professional surrounded by amateurs. Yes she's been in the biz near on 20 years and has had international success, but she in the UK, on a UK show, with three UK judges. Experience and knowledge is great, but not if you're going to rub everyone's noses in it.
4. Gary - As much as I want to like him, I think I've run out of patience. I still respect the guy as an artist and a songwriter, but as a judge, mentor and a personality? Rubbish. He comes across as more interested in himself and using the show as a promotional platform than he is in his acts, most evidently with Frankie. I think a small part of him thought that Frankie would come to his senses and knuckle down if he made it past the first few tentative weeks, and now can't face the reality that had he'd been sterner with the boy, he probably wouldn't have derailed quite so spectacularly. He'd probably blame the other contestants for not attempting to reign Frankie in during their time with him at the house if he thought he could get away with it.
Originally Posted by gladiator18:
“1. Gary - only because he's not afraid to tell the truth ...”
“1. Gary - only because he's not afraid to tell the truth ...”
I think you mean "lie"
All he is doing now is playing tactics. He has started to subtly put down all the other judges' acts that he used to pretend to like.
Let's see if he tells the truth about his own acts tomorrow.
Originally Posted by Rosie Red:
“Not afraid to lie either.”
“Not afraid to lie either.”
Originally Posted by devlinacious:
“I think you mean "lie"
”
“I think you mean "lie"
”
Yes lol he lied, but that doesnt bother me, he's the only judge that makes it interesting for me, the other judges are either too busy crying or being nice even though the performance was awful.
Originally Posted by gladiator18:
“Yes lol he lied, but that doesnt bother me, he's the only judge that makes it interesting for me, the other judges are either too busy crying or being nice even though the performance was awful.”
“Yes lol he lied, but that doesnt bother me, he's the only judge that makes it interesting for me, the other judges are either too busy crying or being nice even though the performance was awful.”
I know what you mean, and I really like Gary (and am a huge TT fan) but he's lost credibility because he chose Frankie who patently couldn't sing a note, praised him when he didn't deserve it, knocked other acts when Frankie was so much worse, and generally came across as a right twazzock.
Originally Posted by Rosie Red:
“I know what you mean, and I really like Gary (and am a huge TT fan) but he's lost credibility because he chose Frankie who patently couldn't sing a note, praised him when he didn't deserve it, knocked other acts when Frankie was so much worse, and generally came across as a right twazzock.”
“I know what you mean, and I really like Gary (and am a huge TT fan) but he's lost credibility because he chose Frankie who patently couldn't sing a note, praised him when he didn't deserve it, knocked other acts when Frankie was so much worse, and generally came across as a right twazzock.”
..and currently going round all the newspapers wearing sackcloth and ashes telling them that what happened to Frankie is everybody's fault.
Surprisingly enough, Tulisa.
I had no idea who she was when the judge spot was announced [and when I did found out her association with Dappy, I groaned hard].
She's been like a breath of fresh air [in Danni's wake] though. Like how down to earth she is.
Louis is, well, Just Louis...
Gary's come off as an arrogant, boring **** [though still wouldn't kick him out of my bed].
And Kelly is very hit and miss.com.
I had no idea who she was when the judge spot was announced [and when I did found out her association with Dappy, I groaned hard].
She's been like a breath of fresh air [in Danni's wake] though. Like how down to earth she is.
Louis is, well, Just Louis...
Gary's come off as an arrogant, boring **** [though still wouldn't kick him out of my bed].
And Kelly is very hit and miss.com.
I've surprised myself by voting Gary. And I'm also surprised to find that Louis is my second favourite. At the start I liked Kelly and Tulisa.
Kelly - she actually makes me laugh and to me appears to be a lot of fun - though obviously high maintenance.
Louis - he actually has been spot on the money with a lot of his comments
Alexandra - I actually liked her refreshing honesty which people have berated her for
Tulisa - in my opinion she is too hard faced and I don't like the way she comes across - but my husband really likes her. Can you imagine if Kelly had berated one of her acts on TV the way she did with Misha - she would not have taken it lying down!
Gary - the things he said to Sammi and last week Johnny were very cruel, way over the top and simply not called for. Does not come across as a nice person at all.
Louis - he actually has been spot on the money with a lot of his comments
Alexandra - I actually liked her refreshing honesty which people have berated her for
Tulisa - in my opinion she is too hard faced and I don't like the way she comes across - but my husband really likes her. Can you imagine if Kelly had berated one of her acts on TV the way she did with Misha - she would not have taken it lying down!
Gary - the things he said to Sammi and last week Johnny were very cruel, way over the top and simply not called for. Does not come across as a nice person at all.
Originally Posted by Dan-Bevis:
“..Gary's come off as an arrogant, boring **** [though still wouldn't kick him out of my bed].
...”
“..Gary's come off as an arrogant, boring **** [though still wouldn't kick him out of my bed].
...”
I think you might find that he kicked you out!
1. Kelly
2 - 3.Louis + Gary equally
4. Tulisa
If it was possible to rate Tulisa lower I would... Predominantly because of her lack of professionalism and integrity concerning how she handled the Misha 'bullying' situation as well as her constant crocodile tears and fake concern.
2 - 3.Louis + Gary equally
4. Tulisa
If it was possible to rate Tulisa lower I would... Predominantly because of her lack of professionalism and integrity concerning how she handled the Misha 'bullying' situation as well as her constant crocodile tears and fake concern.
Originally Posted by sheila blige:
“Louis
Tulisa
I don't even recognise the other two as judges/mentors.”
“Louis
Tulisa
I don't even recognise the other two as judges/mentors.”
Louis and Tulisa
I agree.
Cant bear the site of them either any more.
King Louis!
Always been my favourite judge. Can't believe he's second on this poll though - never thought I'd see the day.
Always been my favourite judge. Can't believe he's second on this poll though - never thought I'd see the day.
Kelly by some considerable distance. It's quite sad that bland old Tulisa is winning. She might ruffle the least feathers, but to be a judge it helps to know a little something about music. She doesn't qualify
Tulisa and Louis.
I hadn't heard of Tulisa before the x factor but she seems to be a good judge and is dedicated to her acts. She also gives costructive criticism. For example she was the only judge last week to pick up on that Janet forgot the words.
I like Louis, even though he says the same cliches a lot, I applaud the fact he took Frankie to task over his horrific performance. That was well overdue!
I hadn't heard of Tulisa before the x factor but she seems to be a good judge and is dedicated to her acts. She also gives costructive criticism. For example she was the only judge last week to pick up on that Janet forgot the words.
I like Louis, even though he says the same cliches a lot, I applaud the fact he took Frankie to task over his horrific performance. That was well overdue!
Tulisa. She's gone from strength to strength.
Such a shame Kelly has gone downhill after how great she was at the auditions.
Such a shame Kelly has gone downhill after how great she was at the auditions.
I'm not sure I'm like any of them at present. Probably Louis by default as least annoying, which is a surprise even to me.
Gary's at the bottom of my list though.
Gary's at the bottom of my list though.
2 of 3
