Rude, brattish with an overinflated sense of entitlement. And people thought Frankie was a bad role model?
I don't dig her voice either, she's a Christina Aguilera impersonator at best.

NOTE: Don't shoot me down, it's only my opinion.

No, you're not. There are tons of threads with people discussing why the brat does not deserve a second shot.

A boy went out of the boys category, a boy should be brought back! SIMPLES!!!!!

Surprise surprise, a female on tv who isn't meek and apologising every step gets pilloried online. Why can't people just accept she is the most talented of the four?

Because your claim is an opinion, not a fact?

I prefer James.

Because in my OPINION (and that's all it is) belting out vocals in a way not dissimilar to a cat vomiting does not make a good singer.

She's a little bitch, slags x factor off, now comes crawling back expecting people to pay to vote for her

I don't want her back ,shes karaoke at best .

Go on then. Who is better? Weak, limp and whiny James? Serial flopper Jonjo? Off pitch 2 Shoes?

I don't see how talent is an opinion either. Amelia's vocal ability and stage presence is a fact. It's like when people on here say "WELL IN MY OPINION THEY WERE OUT OF TUNE" Being in/out of tune isn't an opinion, it's a fact. Either they are or they aren't. You can't say someone isn't talented when all evidence points to the contrary.

i want james back :'(

Actually No. In terms of vocal range and versatility Amelia demolishes the other three.

She has a good voice, but she seems so desperate for fame that I can't seem to find her remotely likeable.

You beat me to it Jem411.

Hopefully this weekend will see her departure finally.
I really dislike all the hype about yet another wannabee.:yawn:

Talent is subjective as to what people WANT from a musician.

I don't want Amelia shouting her way through songs. It does nothing for me, I don't feel a connection when she 'sings'

Yeah, we saw that versatility in her pathetic cover of Billie Jean.

No, I don't think any of them should be put back in

You would have thought so.

Of course this being X Factor it can't be a straightforward as that - hence this pantomime.

I can't understand - please someone explain to me - why Gary loses an act and, because of that, Kelly gains one.

I dont want her back in but these comments are a bit harsh. We dont know her personally she might just come across badly on tv

Talent isn't subjective. Personal preference is. Whitney Heuston is immensely talented, but I prefer listening to Michael Buble. Am I going to say that Michael is more talented than Whitney? No because it's not true.

Also Amelia doesn't "shout her way through songs". Are you for real? Or do you just form your opinion based on what's written on this board.

No you are not the only one OP.

James was void of emotion when singing and it just across as singing by numbers.

Ameila at least will be interesting to watch and has the self confidence to progress further.

Both of them given better song choices would have still been here anyway imo.

I'm basing it on what I hear, and yes, talent is subjective depending on your perception and definition.

Why would someone who is a fan of say Janet/Marcus/ Craig want Amelia to return who may be a threat to thier favourite?

Talent is not subjective. It's something tangible, definable. Your own personal taste and preference is, as I explained in my post. You seem to be getting muddled up.