Am i living in the twilight zone or something - i don't get all the glowing praise from the judges - he wrecked the song for me. Did you guys like it?

Judges rarely tell the truth. Janet was praised 2 weeks ago when she was terrible. Little Mix were praised last week when they were terrible.

I think "you made that song your own" actually means "you slowed that down so much i couldn't tell what it was supposed to be a cover of, but you put a big note at then end and that's all Louis needs to think it's brilliant"

Yes, I loved it.

In your opinion of course.

Marmite it seems.

Of course he murdered it : that was a medicore karaoke version.

actually that version was perform by a kiddo named greyson chance n was superb!

And you can sing yourself??

I have never liked that song no matter who sings it. I was bored listening to Craig sing it.

And what relevance is that?

Craig is in the competition the OP is not

Agreed.


Agree with this also.

Craig id the best singer left and his performance was excellent

Nope, but I am entitled to judge as he is on a talent contest, wants my votes and potentially he wants me to buy his music.......Liked Jar of Hearts, this shocked me because the meaning of the song didnt lend itself to a ballad, I felt the staging was dated, didn't like the lyric change, felt all songs are sounding the same and is coming across dated and a bit camp....I want him to shock me or be cool or something- I can see him winning but not being a pop star.

Thanks for the reminder that people post their opinions on discussion forums.

I thought it was technically the best vocal he has ever done..

Crap crap crap crap crap crap",,,,,,,,,,,imo

It's all propaganda; they've lost all credibility - some more than others.