Being honest with Janet (and everyone else tonight really) and now hugging it out with Louis even with Kelly telling him no! Good on you Gazza!

I'm not sure about Kelly this week for some reason. She seems totally different to the fun, bubbly person we saw on the Graham Norton Show last night...

he's gone down in mine....

good on gary for saying exactly what i was thinking about janet

take a bow mr barlow

Not back up in mine (yet). I'll maybe give him some more time to see.

^^ This

Maybe Frankie going is the best thing that's happened to Gary...

Kelly is the shite causer on the group. The one week she wasn't there everyone got on pretty well. I don't know what her issue is with Louis, but good for Gary to let it all drop.

I think it was pretty obvious that he talked other acts down to cover for the failings he made with his own this week. It was Craig's weakest, and Marcus has only been weaker with Russian Roulette.

Gary was so right on Janet tonight and with what he said about the others apart from Little Mix I think. I think that Little Mix were the second best after Amelia tonight and Kitty done well too!

I was a little disappointed in Marcus tonight, too samey and far too much like last week but not so good!

Bottom 2 for me Janet and Craig! With Janet going!

After seeing the front of tomorrows paper Gary may rethink hugging it out with Louis

Gary Lied because he is Desprate for one of his acts to win and he going to say what ever it takes to help them to win, .Even when he knows it's not true

OP It's funny you should post that because I have finally decided this eve that I've lost all respect for the guy. I have rather a geeky knowledge of all things Queen ( which I won't go into ) but believe me when I say, he was talking UTTER BOLLOCKS on Xtra Factor. If you absolutely NOTHING about a subject, you should prolly keep your mouth shut about it.
Arse

Hmm interesting. Let's see if I can bare him next week or if he goes back to his usual annoying wafting antics and sucks up to Kelly (neverleaveusagain.com)

well said, didnt see this thread otherwise i wouldnt have posted mine, but he's the only judge talking some sense.

ooooooooo what he say

http://img404.imageshack.us/img404/729/staryf.jpg

You are so easy to fool some of you. It's so easy to like him if he happens to compliment your favourite on a particular occasion.

If you watch him over a period of time you can see exactly what he is doing. First he 'loves' everything by a particular act that is not his. Then one week he suddenly turns on them.

He did it with Janet. Now he is doing it with Little Mix. Just keep an eye on his technique. They will be shaken by what he said and next week they will be trying to please him. Whatever they change will be 'wrong'.

The day that he is honest about his own acts is the day I might start to change my mind . Until then I trust him about as far as I could push him up a beach with my legs tied together.

^^^
This!

Remember, this is the man who banged on about how wonderful Frankie was - and we all know what a steaming pile of BS that was.

No. He is the worst judge and mentor ever on TXF, worse than Sharon. He put Frankie through to the live shows, blew smoke up his ass for 5 weeks and tried to convince the rest of us that Frankie had a semblance of talent. On a judging front he is a complete hypocrite. As devlinacious already mentioned he has a system of critiquing that he uses to try and bring down other acts that are a threat to his. The cheek of the man who mentors Marcus and Craig to say that he is getting bored of Janet performing similar songs every week! :O

Well done Gary she was crap tonight

Gary can't have been that spot-on if even the host can put him in his place about his hypocritical views.

Gary is proving to be quite a nasty individual, and not in a funny Simon Cowell way either.

The way she introduced Misha B with a little 'dig' about deserving to have the song both her and Kitty wanted, was so evidently of her shite stirring.

I think he was dead wrong in his comments to Janet.

I had to laugh at Louis (I think it was on the Xtra Factor) saying that Gary's a good singer and songwriter but a hopeless mentor. I agree - I like Take That as a group but don't like Gary's mentoring.