It didn't sound like a generic ballad. It was quite moving.
Did anyone else think Janet's version of Somebody to Love was beautiful?
1 of 6
Originally Posted by caribea:
“It didn't sound like a generic ballad. It was quite moving.”
“It didn't sound like a generic ballad. It was quite moving.”
i thought it was brilliant , but note everybobies cup of tea
Yes, I loved it.
I've just posted this on another thread, but if it was Janet that had been brought back into the show tonight, then everyone here would be raving about her.
I've just posted this on another thread, but if it was Janet that had been brought back into the show tonight, then everyone here would be raving about her.
It wasnt her best work...but regardless I love her voice! Im so glad someone like her is in the competition, we know shes a musician as well. Someone like her deserves to win the show!
Originally Posted by CloudyE:
“No, it was her second worst performance after last week.”
“No, it was her second worst performance after last week.”
I agree.
That said, I reckon she'll be the most successful commercially.
No she managed to ruin a perfectly good song. One of Queen's best and I use to like it until I heard this version.
I didn't expect to like it at all,because this is one of my favourite songs to listen to and to sing,but the arrangement was nice,and in places,for the first time,I liked her tone.
She performed very well,connected with the song,and in places it was lovely,but she needs to reighn in the affectations.They don't need to go completely,but they are distracting,and occasionally not controlled enough,which makes her go briefly pitchy.
Nowhere near the worst of the night.She is getting there,and,again,better acts like her who have potentiial than polished yet consistently mediocre acts with none.
She performed very well,connected with the song,and in places it was lovely,but she needs to reighn in the affectations.They don't need to go completely,but they are distracting,and occasionally not controlled enough,which makes her go briefly pitchy.
Nowhere near the worst of the night.She is getting there,and,again,better acts like her who have potentiial than polished yet consistently mediocre acts with none.
I didn't really like it, her singing was good, but I just found the song incredibly dull. I understand that Kelly didn't want her doing a carbon copy of Somebody to Love, but I just found it boring and lackluster.
Originally Posted by caribea:
“It didn't sound like a generic ballad. It was quite moving.”
“It didn't sound like a generic ballad. It was quite moving.”
It made me move my bowels
Originally Posted by Satnavvy:
“It made me move my bowels”
“It made me move my bowels”
WOW,so,not only did she sing a lovely version,but Janet has more range than we thought..She can hit the mythical , legendary"brown note"!...(and I thought I was cool cos I can shatter crystal.
) Wow!!! Who woulda thought? Holy crap! 
Gary was spot on ... and being from her part of the country and naturally a fan ...... I lost interest too! ...
I found it incredibly beautiful. She so needs a recording contract after this competition, because she just fills a niche in the market and a niche in my iTunes library that needs filling.
1 of 6
