She did, but it was a string of incomprehensible gibberish, which isn't unusual from Kelly.

and surprise surprise she wanted Kitty's.

It was Lady Gaga week and she wanted to sing that song so your reasoning that it can't be a favourite since she didn't sing it in previous weeks doesn't add up.

I've read this a few times, but how was the song Kitty's? Surely there is a rota for picking songs (which seems fair). Why not do a different gaga song?

Stop being melodramatic for nothing.
Kitty could have picked another Gaga song like Bad Romance, Pokerface or Judas. Both Louis and Kitty know how it works that the judges pick songs according to a rota. It was Kellys turn to pick first and she wanted Born this Way. It is immature of Louis to try and get sympathy for Kitty by pretending that her song which was never her song in the first place was stolen.

It was Kitty's because she had been practising it and had to drop it because Misha B wanted to do it. I thought this is obvious.

from what i could tell, it wasnt at the last minute so your wrong there.

secondly Kitty performed it fantastically well

It's quite straight forward but you're trying to assume it's a case of school yard ownership.

Kitty had been learning the song. Why did Kelly choose the song Kitty had been learning? Yes she has first dibs but why later on come along and take Kitty's? It's merely sabotage. Yes Kelly can choose the songs but waiting so late to do it is nothing but sabotage.

It was a pile of rubbish with strange dancers imitating horses. It was comical.

Utter Rubbish, did Kitty say she had been practising Born This Way and it was taken midweek. You are living in fantasy land, that is not how it works. Kelly would have first choice of any songs this week. Kitty would have to wait for Louis to tell her what was left. Many acts have songs they want to do and rarely get to perform.

There is already another thread about this (see Kelly the bully or something!!)

Kitty had no rights over that song. And she did her usual performance. Like a bad tribute act. Shout your way through and wear as little clothes as possible.

I thought they are given a choice of songs selected by the producers and they can only chose from that list.

If Bad Romance, Pokerface, Judas etc aren't on the producer list then she can't sing them

Going 1st...waaah,mean Misha took my song....anything to try to distract from the real reasons she'll be bottom2(again),which are that all the other acts are better, she isn't a good singer &has a mediocre,unpleasantly shrill and nasal voice,and her performances are contrived skill,not talent.

That's exactly how it is. So many people here saying she should have sung another one, but if it isn't on the list they can't sing it.

Someone said the list only has about 20 to choose from, and some of those are probably crap, so the choice is extremely limited.

Singy Thingy seems to have this Joan Crawford/Bette Davis thing going on with Kitty. Lovers tiffs are terrible things.

Didn't like it at all. Showed the worst of Kitty. Too nasal and a lack of subtlety. Maybe her worst perfomance so far. Pretty sure she will go this week.

What do you mean that is not how it works like this is some kind of well oiled machine? This has happened a lot of times in the past and Kelly did it this week.

It's quite straight forward unless you think Kelly Rowland is fantastic because she shared the stage with that overpublicised glorified girl band Destiny's Child or as I call that Dire Calamity.

Louis explained very calmly to kitty that the judges work in rotation when it comes to picking songs and Kelly chose before Louis this week- therefore she did not steal the song - however I think Kitty would have sung it better than Misha did- what goes against Kitty is this dramatic crying and shaking thing that she does every single week- I think if she was more controlled with her emotions she would be more likeable- I think she is a fabulous performer but that crying thing comes across as fake and makes her less credible I feel - which is a shame as she is very very talented.

The whole things a FIX - so I've voted for Kitty several times and hope that I and others spoil their plans

I believe there are a lot of tears backstage that are not shown, and I do think Kittys' were shown to put her in a bad light, however I think it will have the opposite effect, and people will see it for what it is. Kitty will not be in the bottom two

Me too, have voted more than last week for her. Liking your views