Originally Posted by Singy Thingy:
“She may be the weakest vocally,but she's not the least competent vocally,Kitty is.
Janet at least has a technically good if limmited voice,but Kitty's nasal shrill tone isn't fixable,and she's never gonna be more than a 2nd rate Ga Ga with a mediocre voice.”
Im sorry? Janets Voice is not technically good. She consistently fails to hit her low notes. She did it in the initial audition and in every performance since. shes always sharp.
What you mean is Janets is a smooth voice, Kittys is a harder voice, but then so is Mishas. In fact Mishas is the hardest with Kitty sitting in the middle.
Having said that, while i agree Janets was (for the third week in a row) the worst vocal performance (bar Frankie on one occasion), unfortunately Kittys wasnt that far behind last night. She had the death slot and a week (my her standards) performance too.
IF voting went on performances (which it very rarely does) those two would be bottom. THEN Janet SHOULD ve sent packing - you cant excuse 3 weeks on the trot with bad performances and forgotten lyrics. However thats so so so unlikely to happen and Janet would be saved.
The sad truth is, people dont vote on performances, they vote on personality, and maybe for someone they likes at the start (few people change once they get a favourite), so while I expect Kitty to be in the bottom two - I have no idea who will join her. Marcus wasnt that strong but seems to have just as big a fan base as Janet. Misha actually did quite well last nigh but HAS been bottom 2 before so could be in contention. It wont matter though - as its Kittys week to be toast.