Originally Posted by gussiecat:
“Thank you very much for responding. Just curious do they not chit chat on the JAT?
Also I dont think there is a party line on here. Many people may think like me that John and Josie are happy in their lives now. That Josie is doing well, John is most probably very happy too.
Some people would love them to reunite, others wish they could at least be friends, myself included friends not reunited. They shared such an amazing and huge event in their lives it seems sad that they are no longer even nodding friends.
Some people have opinions that there is something not quite right about Josie and Luke, perhaps because of a general cynicism to all magazine articles abt relationships, like the ones previously mentioned and Kerry katona, Katie Price, Chantelle Houghton type articles. Others believe it all.
Some people think Josie looks great and is great in everything , others that she still needs to polish her tv appearances and that sometimes like every normal girl she looks better than others.
What I do know is that the one joint thought on this thread is that everyone wishes them BOTH well.”
As you know from reading it, I don't participate that much. My participation there is mainly about what's going on with Josie.
Originally Posted by
wongos123:
“Hello Ferfer
This as you say is a John and Josie thread and i do personally believe Josie is with Luke as i believed John James when he did his mag deal......i have not seen anyone called Josie a liar though...if they have i agree should not be done on here...if people chose not to believe either of them...that is their choice.....it doesn't hurt me..does it hurt Josie or John...doubt it very much..... nor does it hurt me when people post chit and chat ....im one of biggest culprits...again i dont get why any one gets upset with that...
One thing you have not answered though from Gussie i note, you never defend John James on here when anyone says anything negative or offensive .....when you defend Josie you do so because as you say rightly it is a John James and Josie apprecation thread ......i think this is why some people get upset on here........if it is a John James and Josie thread and you feel the need to come in a defend Josie for that reason...why not John.....”
I didn't say there was anything wrong with chit chat. I just said that I don't participate in it. I haven't since thread 1. It's not a new thing. I've been here to discuss Josie and John. I get my chit chat elsewhere.
John doesn't need defending, as no one says anything against him. I can remember it happening twice in months and other people have jumped on it immediately. Yet it's an almost daily occurrence for Josie to be put down here. Sad, isn't it?
Example, there was a tweet from Josie this week where she said she's finished her to do list and had started on another and she was excited. I think one person posted a positive response while the other responses I read were complaints about her not sharing more info, that her new list probably wasn't much since we didn't hear about her other list much, and on and on. I didn't mention it because if I brought up each and every time this happened that's all I would post about.
But today when someone says that they don't believe Josie's in a relationship, when she personally has said she is, and that she's manipulating the media and basically selling a story instead of having a real relationship? That went too far in my opinion and stated it. LOL, and I'm the one who's being negative.
Again, I find it odd that only my views are questioned. I have to justify why I post here? That's ludicrous.
Originally Posted by Dongle44:
“long time lurker here. feel so sorry for regular upbeat posters on here especially tonite. have so often wanted to post especialy all the lovely poems etc but all the defending on one side has put me off and off. I was going to join in here tonite but all the negative posts put me off and I feel so sorry for Wendy and all the regular posters with what they have to deal with”
Welcome. I again find it odd that the negative posts are mine, trying to understand why it's okay to insinuate that Josie's lying about being in a relationship. Perplexing at the very least. The negative posts aren't digs at Josie or her honesty? A desire for reconciliation shouldn't justify defamation of character.
But hey, it's obviously just me.