• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Best ever mentor (X Factor/Voice)
mashamoto79
20-11-2011
Not judge but mentoring the acts during the show and afterwards.

Far and away Blake Shelton has to take it. And he was also a pretty good judge as well.
Tyjet
20-11-2011
Tulisa.
Satanel
20-11-2011
I would actually say Paula has been the best mentor I've seen (XFUSA).
bobsicle
20-11-2011
In the UK, Dannii Minogue by a country mile.
Tyjet
20-11-2011
Originally Posted by bobsicle:
“In the UK, Dannii Minogue by a country mile.”

I would have to disagree with this completely. The only good thing about Dannii's mentoring was the fact that she cared the most out of the other judges, but she quite often got it badly wrong with song choices.
InMyArms
20-11-2011
I've been impressed by Tulisa and Paula Abdul.
Bumtiddlywinks
20-11-2011
louis. The only judge to take a group to 2nd place.

And can you imagine any other judge coping with the overs as well as Louie does?

Can you imagine Barlow or Kelly working with a 50 year old Tesco cashier?
Dan!
20-11-2011
Dannii Minogue.
Nobody Knows
20-11-2011
Christina!
Janette800
20-11-2011
Dannii without a doubt
XNotASaintX
20-11-2011
Tulisa
1lennonlove
20-11-2011
Got to be Danni,

Last year she had Matt Cardle's name as a cover on her phone. Matt always said Danni knew the right things to say to make him feel better. She is loyal, hardworking and listens to the artist. Best mentor without a doubt mainly because she actually understood what is meant by mentoring.

Can't say for US or other talent shows. Only watch X Factor UK.
Janette800
20-11-2011
Originally Posted by 1lennonlove:
“Got to be Danni,

Last year she had Matt Cardle's name as a cover on her phone. Matt always said Danni knew the right things to say to make him feel better. She is loyal, hardworking and listens to the artist. Best mentor without a doubt mainly because she actually understood what is meant by mentoring.

Can't say for US or other talent shows. Only watch X Factor UK.”

Dannii still keeps in touch with Matt...they had a night out the last time she was here
1lennonlove
20-11-2011
Originally Posted by Janette800:
“Dannii still keeps in touch with Matt...they had a night out the last time she was here”

Says it all
rivercity_rules
20-11-2011
Tulisa is best mentor I think, she's made her groups that were thrown together, feel like they'd been together for years.

She's not the best judge, I think her comments are slightly lacking, but as a mentor she's great.
gagafan2010
20-11-2011
Dannii, Tulisa and Paula for me.

Tulisa is a shit judge though.
KillerJoe
20-11-2011
Originally Posted by gagafan2010:
“Dannii, Tulisa and Paula for me.”

These 3 for me too. Paula puts so much effort into her groups on XF:USA.. I feel so bad for her that she's lost 2 already!
JMTD
20-11-2011
Seriously, no mention of Cowell yet? I know it's 'cool' to hate on him, but wow.

He'd be my choice. Doing a great job currently and has done in the past. Some times disagree with his decisions or choices, but overall comes across as a brilliant mentor.
superstar111
20-11-2011
As much as its the 'in' thing on Digital Spy to hate her, Cheryl Cole done a pretty great job during her reign on the show.. Diana Vickers, Alexandra Burke, Cher Lloys, Rebecca Ferguson all shone under her wing.

Tulisa is the best one thusfar IMO. Little Mix have become a force to be reckoned with!
Tfan26
20-11-2011
Originally Posted by superstar111:
“As much as its the 'in' thing on Digital Spy to hate her, Cheryl Cole done a pretty great job during her reign on the show.. Diana Vickers, Alexandra Burke, Cher Lloys, Rebecca Ferguson all shone under her wing.

Tulisa is the best one thusfar IMO. Little Mix have become a force to be reckoned with!”

agreed with this, Cheryl didn't win twice in a row for nothing, she nearly got a hat trick aswell.

Tulisa is doing FANTASTIC with Little Mix, she was doing great with The Risk aswell before they were eliminated .
iluvdannii
20-11-2011
Dannii was brilliant yeh ok she made some wrong song choices but what judge hasn't!!? and i do think blake shelton was a good mentor on The Voice! plus paula is good as well!
Burkette
20-11-2011
Kelly the only mentor who has managed to get 3 acts so far.Danni as well a supportive and generous mentor.
suniil
20-11-2011
Danni Minogue and Blake Shelton
cgnboi
20-11-2011
UK: Danni Minogue, US: Paula Abdul, Oz: Natalie Imbruglia
Vanquish32
20-11-2011
Blake Shelton by a country mile.

He not only mentored Dia (his act) during the show, but - after the show- introduced her to well-known music stars and song-writers, thereby enabling her to create contacts. And to top it off, he let her be the opening act for his concerts, increasing her exposure.

I haven't seen any uk x factor judge give that level of support to a contestant.
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map