and she didn't answer him.

Gary answered it for her. And I thought it was a good answer. Amelia wasn't very good in the first liveshow. Sophie was.

Why can't Kelly answer her own questions?

Because half of the time she doesn't even know what the british people are saying? Because she doesn't really want to be on this show? Who knows!

^^^
This! Someone had to go and Amelia was the weakest of the girls, so it was a no-brainer really.

She hasn't had any issues understanding Louis before, and not wanting to be on the show is hardly an excuse given the figure on her pay cheque.

I'm just making reasons up as I go, haha. So why do you think Gary answered it for her then?

Because she doesn't seem to be able to even follow her own train of thoughts let alone another's enough to answer them. What was she going on about with Craig's critique?

I thought she was losing it but what with getting rid of what has turned out such favourite, Amelia, I'm begining to wonder if she ever had it.

I think he sees himself as in charge, and therefore responsible for answering difficult questions.

It was not a difficult question to answer, it was a stupid question, that did not need to be answered. Kelly is not answerable to shite stirring Walsh.


No one questioned him why he put through gimmick Johnny, over ppl who could sing?

Kelly probably didn't answer because she didn't want to stoop to Louis's level of unprofessionalism, and give the tabloids more fodder.

Not forgetting that Louis was the same person who wanted to put Goldie Chung through rather than somebody who could actually sing. Thank God, Goldie saw the light, and refused to be used as this years' Wagner.