Like im thinking they shuld bring sharon osbourne back

Is that a joke? Seriously? I like Kelly, and I did like Sharon until her ugly treatment of Danni showed that she should never be given a platform on the X Factor again to spit her hate-filled venom.

They shouldn't bring Sharon back. IRL she is allegedly worse than Kelly, just swap annoying acted childish americanisms for 2 faced concealed genuine nastiness.

If they are going to bring back anyone I think we can all agree the popular choice should be Cheryl.

They both have their fans and haters but I imagine Sharon would be less popular now than Kelly (give or take the vocal minority on this forum!)

Her Americanisms sometimes grate, she really ought to have put Jade through to the live shows and she doesn't pick the greatest songs for her acts, but yes, I do like her.

There's three new judges this year, so they're all going to make silly mistakes. Before this year, there was generally only one new judge, so mistakes a-plenty have been made. I don't get the dislike for her.

Er, no we don't. I'm a GA fan, but even I don't want Cheryl back. Her smoozefest with Simon last year was revolting.

I can't really comment as I don't know who Kelly Roland is. But on the other hand, I do like Kelly Rowland.

True

Me and I don't get it either. Kelly is like the fun bits of Louis (Barlow got the irritating bits).

She'll always be one third of Destiny's Child to me........or one quarter, depending on which era we're talking about.

As such, I like her.

[quote=86lphillips;54718895]They shouldn't bring Sharon back. IRL she is allegedly worse than Kelly, just swap annoying acted childish americanisms for 2 faced concealed genuine nastiness.

If they are going to bring back anyone I think we can all agree the popular choice should be Cheryl.[/QUOTE]

No we can't.

She seem alright.

If there was a poll - I'd bet my house Cheryl would get the most votes over Osbourne and Rowland.

I'm definitely over Cheryl now. I would replace Tulisa with Dannii.

I'd agree with that

I love Kelly, she's fun and doesnt seem to hold back when she has something to say.

I like her when she behaves like a sane person, but when she overdoes it or makes underhanded comments towards Tulisa it just makes her seem silly/petty.

Danni is the second worst judge ever after Osbourne/Rowland. She also used to come out with passive aggressive snide comments disguised as anything but - mostly directed towards Louis.

Sharon was a lot of fun, and never boring. Kelly is just awful.

To answer the title of your thread nope!

Completely disagree,

Loved her as a solo artist
think she is a poor mentor and judge
i have gone off her alot lately so will i buy future albums? not sure
i think Kelly may have lost a few fans after xfactor

Thanks for sharing

You're very welcome.

Kelly Rocks.