Interesting poll

Remember its multiple choice, so you can vote for any number of the four, including all of them.

Well, Louis since he's grown on me this year. Perhaps due to speaking out about Frankie and choosing Kitty & Johnny as 2 of his final 3. =P

I'm indifferent with Tulisa. I wouldn't mind, I guess.

Kelly? No. Just. No. Yes, some comments she comes out with are great, but, in the live shows, she's borderline unbearable. I just wanna throw my pen at her, and say, "shut it, girl! Shut it!"

Gary? He's really not done anything for himself by joining the panel and letting the likes of Frankie through. If he weren't a judge, and was watching the show, he would've slammed Frankie. He'll probably not return. Damage limitation etc.

As long as Louis is back...

Tulisa and Louis

Tulisa

Gary and Kelly

Kelly and Gary.

Tulisa & Louis!

To be honest, none of them! They all annoy me!

TuTu & LouLou! :P <3 them both

Loulisa forever, obvs.

Ah, it seems that Louis isn't so hated after all
Realistically speaking he should have been made the head judge this year

Louis and since she told the mob to shut up last night, Kelly.

I find Gary and Tulisa to be the most obviously tactical and childish. Replace them with some judges who will actually pick up on vocal issues.

No, who could hate Louis? But I don't think he should be Head Judge. He still has a tendency to put too many novelty acts through, and his comments are the same every week; it's getting quite comical now. "Manchester/Ireland/Essex/Outer Mongolia should pick up the phone and VOTE for you!".

Bless Louis, he's great but he's no Head Judge.

Louis-Yes as he's an original judge and part of the furniture
Tulisa - don't mind either way
Kelly No no no can't bear her and her Y'all anymore
Gary no as i don't think he's been that good and looks seems disinterested most of the time

Kelly and Louis. Bring back Dannii and a new male judge into the mix.

I like Gary. It would be a shame to lose Louis - who will bring the joke acts?? Kelly if she improves.

Tulisa. Ooooh Tulisa lol I had such high hopes for her, her personality is being drowned.

Playing Devil's advocate for a moment: What if someone wanted to vote none of them back?

Louis brings the banter to the panel, although I don't think much of his mentoring dare I say it

I don't want Kelly back.

The other two can take or leave.

Simon Louis Kelly and Tulisa would be good...

Tulisa, Louis, Dannii and Simon would be my panel of choice for 2012 but chances are it will never happen and i am not holding out much hope!

I would only like to see Tulisa back as she has gone back up in my estimations. I liked Kelly initially, but would prefer it if she wasn't back on the panel next year - I'm sorry to say, her mannerisms are far too irritating for my liking.

Is it just me though who thinks he's being told to behave this way by the producers? In the same way that Gary was made become the 'mean' judge, Louis is the jokey, easy to make fun of judge. I mean, let's be honest here, Louis is a multi-millionaire, he's obviously not a stupid person, so why behave this way on the show?

That's right - there should be a 'none of them' option

Not sure if I'm in the minority but I wouldn't mind Alexandra coming back - I think I'd prefer her to Kelly

Tulisa! <3