Gary and kelly
Results:Which judges do you want to see return? (Multiple choice, vote as many as you like!)
Gary
47 (20.80%)
Kelly
58 (25.66%)
Tulisa
142 (62.83%)
Louis
162 (71.68%)
Voters: 226. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Multiple choice, which judges do you want to see return in 2012?
2 of 3
I would hate it if Louis didn't return. He is by far the best judge and always gives honest opinions. I have truly gone off Gary as he has made some disastrous choices with his contestants and he says completely the opposite to what I have been thinking a lot of the time. Like last week I was mesmorised by Janet's rendition of Somebody to love, but he said he was bored.
I think that Kelly Rowland has been awful! At first I liked her, but as time has worn on, she has begun to really grate on me.
Tulisa, I grow hot and cold with. Sometimes, I find her to be quite warm towards the contestants, but I find her comments very unoriginal and full of cliches.
I think that Kelly Rowland has been awful! At first I liked her, but as time has worn on, she has begun to really grate on me.
Tulisa, I grow hot and cold with. Sometimes, I find her to be quite warm towards the contestants, but I find her comments very unoriginal and full of cliches.
Louis and Tulisa for sure. The show wouldn't be the same about Louis and Tulisa seems like a great mentor.
I voted Tulisa and Louis.
I love Gary but think he has been poor in the live shows, he was much better in the audition stage.
I liked Kelly during the auditions but she is really bad on the lives.
I love Gary but think he has been poor in the live shows, he was much better in the audition stage.
I liked Kelly during the auditions but she is really bad on the lives.
Louis, Gary should stick to what he is good at, so should Kelly, I don't care if I never set eyes on Tulisa again. They need Louis, who else will make the best of the duff catagory without whinning.
I'm not keen on any of them, but I'd say Louis and Tulisa - Louis' okay and Tulisa is quite a good mentor. Gary and Kelly are both very annoying to watch and not particularly good mentors, either.
I think Loise worked well when Danni was a judge. Kelly & Gary just argue to much over anything and everything
2 of 3
