I started off this X Factor being a big fan supporter of hers -but now I have my doubts.

I actually wanted her to go tonight -and sure she does have the voice but shes starting to leave me cold ???

Something missing?

Nope not atall, she reminds me of two of my fav singers Kelly Clarkson and Pink

I love Amelia. She is sassy, confident and has a powerful voice - all things to be celebrated.

I started off liking two James Michael and the Risk. I was gutted that James did not get through, and thought Marcus should have gone, although have to say singing wise it should have been Frankie, as Marcus has totally won me over, as for Amelia, I thought she was the weakest that night and deserved to go, and bringing her back for me was not the right thing to do. She did shout her song, whether people like the way Gary put it or not, he was in fact right, for me Louis should have booted off Amelia and not Craig, like you she tends to leave me cold.

I don't like her attitude.

I did actually like her up until judge's houses and the first live shows and was surprised and disappointed she didn't get through but since she's been back I see why Kelly didn't choose her to go through. I really don't rate her at all.

I actually think shes gone from the chosen one(to have back) then something has happened ?

The song choices for this girl have been awful!

If you go off someone you were never a true fan in the first place.
The contestant is better of without you......

she hasnt got the greatest personality.

No, I was never on her in the first place

Haha -I like her voice ,but since having seeing her more which I never really had the opportunity since she went really soon-I find her cold.

Sorry but its just my opinion and I am allowed that!

I do not agree with you, if someone sings songs you do not like or their personality starts to really show and you don't like it you go off them, simple as that really, and the person said she liked her not she was a fan, there is a subtle difference.

she is a bit cold. Amd she keeps saying 'I only just came back'.After hoping she'd win last week, I have gone off her a little.

Glad she stayed over Caig though. Didnt get the hype for him and Gary losing is quite amusing.

she looks like a pop star, but does shout more than sing!

She has a great voice but looks as rough as hell. I would not like to mess with her, I bet she can could handle herself in a fight, watch out Barlow she could talke you in a second.

She can sing all right but I was never 'on' here so it's difficult to go off her.

I don't think she has any chance of winning at all but I reckon she could end up fourth or even third at a pinch.

Boy - some of you are really harsh. I think she was a bit overhyped after she was booted out, but she's done two powerful performances since she came back. A bit shouty, buit she's a nice looking girl and a good performer. She's not my favourite, but I don't get the criticism about her looks or her voice really.

I never warmed to her as a person. Yes no doubt she can sing , but something about her annoys me. Just cant put my finger on it.

Im not saying anything of the sort .I just feel that she doesn't have that star personality that I thought she had at the start?

Something missing lol

The criticisms are from sad ugly people. Whilst she is no Miss World, she's not unattractive and she can sing.

Lol!

I haven't said anything like that!?

And Im not a sad ugly lonely person haha-Im a fox!

Really is your first name Neil by any chance!

I dont like her attitude and ego. But there's no denying the girls got talent .. It would be a bit unfair if she won though she would have only sang like what about 8 times?

Lol!!!!

Well I have to be honest here -NO-for a start Im a girl lol

Sorry, my remark wasn't especially aimed at you, or any one person in this thread, in general, more at posters on this board that are continually attacking individuals with their "hate" campaigns. One just gets a bit fed up