Will Young would have been a good one for the list. He's been through the process in Pop Idol, is still going strong 10 years later and was an excellent guest mentor.
Results:vote for judge of your choice
GARY BARLOW
44 (22.68%)
TULISA
98 (50.52%)
KELLY ROWLAND
47 (24.23%)
LOUIS WALSH
96 (49.48%)
ROBBIE WILLIAMS
35 (18.04%)
BONO
19 (9.79%)
ANNIE LENNOX
29 (14.95%)
PAUL WELLER
16 (8.25%)
DANNI MINOGUE
98 (50.52%)
CHERYL COLE
61 (31.44%)
Voters: 194. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Which Judges Do You Want Next Year ??
2 of 3
Originally Posted by oxygenjj:
“gary and rob on the same panel would that work”
“gary and rob on the same panel would that work”
It probably wouldnt work but out of the list you provided that is I would like to them see on the show.
Originally Posted by hannah:
“It probably wouldnt work but out of the list you provided that is I would like to them see on the show.”
“It probably wouldnt work but out of the list you provided that is I would like to them see on the show.
”
ok i take that ( as a good answer)
Originally Posted by oxygenjj:
“ok i take that ( as a good answer)”
“ok i take that ( as a good answer)”
My Ultimate Line up would be
Simon
Gary
Kelly
Cheryl
Originally Posted by hannah:
“My Ultimate Line up would be
Simon
Gary
Kelly
Cheryl”
“My Ultimate Line up would be
Simon
Gary
Kelly
Cheryl”
didn't put simon on the poll because hes got another year on his contract in the us
not sure about danni as shes in the aussie version now
Originally Posted by oxygenjj:
“didn't put simon on the poll because hes got another year on his contract in the us
not sure about danni as shes in the aussie version now”
“didn't put simon on the poll because hes got another year on his contract in the us
not sure about danni as shes in the aussie version now”
Oh ok but this is my dream line up
Originally Posted by oxygenjj:
“gary not as popular as i thought interesting”
“gary not as popular as i thought interesting”
It doesnt suprise me a load of people dont like him
Originally Posted by denton178:
“Dannii all the way for me they were stupid to let her go”
“Dannii all the way for me they were stupid to let her go”
yeah she was very good
Out of that lot - Annie, Robbie, Cheryl & Gary.
Louis Walsh has got to go. We're sick of joke acts. And dear god, please keep Danni away. She bores me to tears.
Louis Walsh has got to go. We're sick of joke acts. And dear god, please keep Danni away. She bores me to tears.
Louis, definitely. X Factor isn't X Factor without Louis
Tulisa, give her another chance. She isn't bad apart from a lack of knowledge of music (THINK about it.)
Annie Lennox who be good but a couple of others I would suggest:
Female - Alexandra Burke (yes, her for you haters. She was brill as a stand in.) If not her someone like Alison Moyet or Carol Decker.
Male - Jeff Lynne (ELO), Simon Le Bon (Duran Duran) or Peter Cox (Go West) could be good.
Definite NNNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO to Simon, Cheryl, Danni, Nicole, Gary and Kelly. All wastes of space, especially Simon and Cheryl.
Tulisa, give her another chance. She isn't bad apart from a lack of knowledge of music (THINK about it.)
Annie Lennox who be good but a couple of others I would suggest:
Female - Alexandra Burke (yes, her for you haters. She was brill as a stand in.) If not her someone like Alison Moyet or Carol Decker.
Male - Jeff Lynne (ELO), Simon Le Bon (Duran Duran) or Peter Cox (Go West) could be good.
Definite NNNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO to Simon, Cheryl, Danni, Nicole, Gary and Kelly. All wastes of space, especially Simon and Cheryl.
Wow. Tulisa is coming first. I didn't expect that. It's great though because I think she connects the best with her acts and really tries to be a good judge. Next year I'd like to see:
Tulisa
Dannii
Louis
Nicole (she isn't working on the US version
I like her though and she was great on the UK panel)
Tulisa
Dannii
Louis
Nicole (she isn't working on the US version
I like her though and she was great on the UK panel)
I am quite surprised out of those lot the 4 most popular so far are Louis, Dannii, Tulisa and Cheryl.
I expected Dannii and Tulisa to be popular but no way did I think Louis and Cheryl would be.
I expected Dannii and Tulisa to be popular but no way did I think Louis and Cheryl would be.
I must be losing it, cause I voted for Louis
We need Louis to continue to get the weirdos and for him to continue with his insane love of everything Irish, he is a ridiculous judge and he is so right for this ridiculous show.
We need Louis to continue to get the weirdos and for him to continue with his insane love of everything Irish, he is a ridiculous judge and he is so right for this ridiculous show.
Originally Posted by mmeister2:
“Wow. Tulisa is coming first. I didn't expect that. It's great though because I think she connects the best with her acts and really tries to be a good judge. Next year I'd like to see:
Tulisa
Dannii
Louis
Nicole (she isn't working on the US version I like her though and she was great on the UK panel)”
“Wow. Tulisa is coming first. I didn't expect that. It's great though because I think she connects the best with her acts and really tries to be a good judge. Next year I'd like to see:
Tulisa
Dannii
Louis
Nicole (she isn't working on the US version
I like her though and she was great on the UK panel)”
maybe i need a bigger poll
Why is Louis guaranteed a spot next year. He will again have a group of older acts that will all be out half way through. It is ridiculous that he is the comic clown of the panel.
2 of 3
