I'd love to see Gary, Tulisa, Dannii and perhaps Tom Fletcher (McFly) to replace Louis? I'd love to see what a man younger than 40 would do when being a mentor.

if tulisa saw this vote she would be well chuffed

I'd like Gary and Tulisa to go. Gary too smug and too harsh. Tulisa has an awful lack of musical knowledge and is a massive hypocrite.

I seem to be in the minority but I like Kelly, and I think we need Louis to keep some sort of consistency. I'd love Charlotte Church to be a judge (though she'd be more suited to The Voice) because she's feisty and knows her stuff, and would love Will Young as a male judge.

I'd also love Dannii back... but also hope that she's moved on from the whole charade now.

I've always said that Annie would be a great mentor. The chances of her doing X Factor are zero though. We do need a Scot on the panel so as ever I suggest KT Tunstall. She's smart, credible, hilarious and down to Earth. Not sure if she has a high opinion of reality TV though.

They have to keep Louis but make him "head judge". I agree with the poster who said a younger male would be a welcome addition to the panel. Will Young I guess would be a good signing but maybe one of the McFly guys wold work.

Bonnie Tyler would be a fun judge too, she's nice but a bit nuts too.

Louis
Robbie
Tulisa
Dannii

Cheryl for the US show.

Holy crapola, what depressing poll results!

I feel they should all go. Kelly's getting on my nerves with the way she acts sometimes, Tulisa is just ridiculously limited in her musical knowledge (how can she not know any Aretha Franklin songs?), Gary's very up himself & Louis is...just Louis.

Mind you, if they get rid of them all, they might bring someone in like Pixie Lott!

Umm...it was one Aretha Franklin song, not all of them. She definitely knows Aretha Franklin because there was an audition (can't remember who) and she knew it.

Xx..xX

Lousis, Tulisa, Danni Minogue ( my fav judge), don t care who else

Cheryl Louis Tulisa was going to vote four but i couldnt find Sharon Osbourn!

thats why i added some new options in the poll

how many votes would tulisa get if this poll was done before the x factor auditions

why ??

this forum has spoken

after this week , would your vote still count